search

ledgerloops / ledgerloops.com

Contents of https://ledgerloops.com
https://ledgerloops.com
9 stars 0 forks source link

netting at equilibrium #78

Open michielbdejong opened 6 years ago

michielbdejong commented 6 years ago

when resolving a loop, each participants makes a small profit (that is their motivation for participating), but it's hard to make sure this profit gets distributed fairly, due to the diner's dilemma.

a possible solution for this is to slowly resolve loops with small amounts at a time. Whoever is in more of a hurry pays the higher fee. making it go slower may sound annoying UX, but it's actually useful, since it will mean you just wait for other payments to net against. "later" is a compromise between "yes" and "no", and also the money isn't tied up while it's unsettled. suppose there is a triangular flow of goods, continuously topping up a debt cycle, and it's against its limits, so the faster the cycle is resolved, the faster more goods can continue to flow. if all participants want these goods to flow, they can increase the chunk amounts to increase throughput. whoever is in more of a hurry to send more goods, pays a higher transaction fee to make the debt cycle resolution go faster.

michielbdejong commented 6 years ago

'unsettled' is a nice pun on 'unsettling'... become unsettled by LedgerLoops! :)

Should describe netting at equilibrium on the website, but explain that for now, for simplicity, loops go at UCR rates.

michielbdejong commented 8 months ago

Reopening this since I think i might want to switch from UCR to N@E.

michielbdejong commented 8 months ago

There was some serious pushback against this approach at CoFi#23:

[paraphrasing] if we build market making into our tools then the way users of these tools are invited to behave is not collaborative

But I still feel haggling might be OK.