legoboyvdlp / A320-family

A high-quality Airbus A320 simulation for the open source simulator, FlightGear
GNU General Public License v2.0
126 stars 41 forks source link

Feature Request - Cockpit Tablet #224

Open AAL5665 opened 3 years ago

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

Will it be possible to add a screen touch tablet(in relation to A350 MCDU's screen touch interface), if so, will it be possible to make it capable of doing the following:

  1. Display simbrief related option such as: i. Route(while showing the flight progress as well) ii. Time until arrival iii. Callsign(Not necessary but a suggestion) iv. Able to import simbrief flightplan OFP or printout(this might be asking for a lot) v. Distance till you reach the Arrival Airport.

  2. Control aircraft doors,

  3. Connect External Power and Air.

merspieler commented 3 years ago

We have ideas for it... but won't come until near completion of the actual systems.

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

Sure fine by me

legoboyvdlp commented 3 years ago

Control aircraft doors,

Connect External Power and Air.

This doesn't make sense. Those are performed by ground crew; not in a "tablet" device.

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

Okay understood was referring to the FBW A320 EFB

On Sat, Apr 3, 2021 at 1:45 PM legoboyvdlp @.***> wrote:

Control aircraft doors,

Connect External Power and Air.

This doesn't make sense. Those are performed by ground crew; not in a "tablet" device.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/legoboyvdlp/A320-family/issues/224#issuecomment-812867496, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARZWQSEFRSO76EM2ISMSOATTG4LWRANCNFSM42KD2GLQ .

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

@legoboyvdlp X-Plane has a plugin called Avi-Tab and allows you to control those things in it. It is your choice whether you want to combine the two or keep them separate.

Octal450 commented 3 years ago

Yes! I have been working on this on and off for the past few years... its something I will likely look into once the FDM (which is keeping most of my time rn) is complete!

Kind Regards, Josh

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Oh... and just FYI @AAL5665 :

ii. Time until arrival

That will be visible on the MCDU, once completed

iii. Callsign(Not necessary but a suggestion)

Already on the MCDU F-PLN page

iv. Able to import simbrief flightplan OFP or printout(this might be asking for a lot)

You can already import from simbrief....

v. Distance till you reach the Arrival Airport.

Again, already available on the F-PLN page... as well you can use the PROG pages BRG/DIST function to get the directe distance

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

I was thinking instead of having menus to do stuff like push back or enable ground power, we put it in this tablet.

merspieler commented 3 years ago

doesn't make any sense... on a real tablet you wouldn't have that...

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

But in real life, you wouldn't have menus either. Technically both are unrealistic. And this tablet isn't like an iPad tablet. It is a special tablet. :)

merspieler commented 3 years ago

well... at least we can keep the tablet realistic... by not including that. ... and some airlines actually use iPads...

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

I believe that the idea for this tablet is not like a regular tablet. It is supposed to be like a control center for the plane but also a place for references like charts. Ultimately, this is you people's decision but those were just my two cents.

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Don't steal the bad ideas from the commercial sims :P

Octal450 commented 3 years ago

I actually think its a good idea @merspieler (to put the acconfig menus and sh*t in there) :D

Kind Regards, Josh

merspieler commented 3 years ago

cause the commercial crap does it?

inuyaksa commented 3 years ago

My two cents. I don't like a fake tablet on this plane, I prefer a realistic table with all the functions a real pilot can use. Other needed functions can be implemented on menu or acconfig.

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

Hey, maybe add a toggle, if you like the idea, then enable it, if you don't, you can disable it and just use the menus! :)

Octal450 commented 3 years ago

cause the commercial crap does it?

Nah, just because its a convenient place to put stuff imo vs clumsy menus.

Not a requirement I just thought it would be cool. We can decide on it later anyways, take a vote and see who likes what.

Kind Regards, Josh

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

Wow this is quite the discussion

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

My two cents. I don't like a fake tablet on this plane, I prefer a realistic table with all the functions a real pilot can use. Other needed functions can be implemented on menu or acconfig.

Currently you are aware that the NAV mode only displays the F-PLN in a certain distance and the function of the route manager is none existing. Even if you use the F-PLN mode to view the result aren't different.

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

If there is a wish for such realism then there should be voice commands which might be used in controlling the ground crew(which might not be necessary) through the use of the MECH button for communication(initiation of commands). Do not forget that in reality the doors are opened by the cabin crew which if you would want that then you might need that voice command option via the CALL button on the overhead panel to initiate the command.

Ignore If against the idea do not read the following:

Just know this is personal preference(suggestion) ignore if you must.

Toggle in aircraft config to enable or disable VC option Function: if mech_button press then VC(voice command) enable then if mech_button press again disable VC

if call_button press then VC(voice command) enable then if call_button press disable VC

Execution: Mech commands: Connect External Power Connect External Air Connect Catering Truck Connect Baggage Ramp/Cart

Call commands: Open Doors Close Doors Announcement(condition to be met before it can starts)

Just know this is personal preference(suggestion) ignore if you must.

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Here is your distance: fgfs-20210404231814

There is already voice control for a few functions... https://github.com/merspieler/flight-gear-copilot tho this is a very generic implementation and hasn't been updated in a while. Adding stuff to it would be easy tho

Actually that CABIN/MECH buttons aren't that much of a bad idea... Voice commands are probably a bit overkill but if you click the MECH button and you get a dialog for the things you mentioned, that would be neat... maybe with spoken dialog....

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

In addition, could the PAX, Cargo, FOB be displayed. For example,

if: Forward Cabin = 3722 Centre Cabin = 2721 Aft Cabin = 4233 then PAX = Forward Cabin + Centre Cabin + Aft / 100

if total == 10676 / 100 then total = 106.7 or 107

if: Forward Cargo = 3000 Aft Cargo = 3000 then

Cargo = Forward Cargo + Aft Cargo / 1000 if Cargo == 6000/1000 Cargo = 6.0

Display on tablet in a tab(Fuel And Payload tab) PAX: 106.7 Cargo: 6.0

merspieler commented 3 years ago

If you already know, you're off topic, then why do you post it in the first place???? (post removed) Your question is better asked on the forum so I won't answer here-

For weight an pax... there was the idea of having an actual load sheet....

As said before, I'd prefer to have something similar to a real tablet on it and anything which is limited to the sim in a separate dialog.

Oh... and please DO NOT reference other sims, DO reference official documents or other references of the real thing.

legoboyvdlp commented 3 years ago

Real: image image image image image image image

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

Does this tablet actually come with the plane? Or do the airlines install them? Because it seems like some are a bit different...

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Afaik, they are up to the airlines. They are also not really integrated into the systems like the OIS in the A350 is.

Last pic is interesting... (despite that it's an A330), it seems to be integrated into the table, similar to the Keyboard on the A380 and A350.

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

Real: image image image image image image image

Is this going to have to include Navigraph as well for the charts?

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Only if YOU pay for it

Octal450 commented 3 years ago

Yep... ^

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

I mean... we're not going to give you Navigraph for free...

AAL5665 commented 3 years ago

I was asking whether it will require Navigraph for the charts. @legoboyvdlp Regarding the first issue about the flightplan being displayed on the tablet:

Charts

This is in the photo right?

NewoIsTaken commented 3 years ago

Ah, the US has charts for free published by the FAA, the UK has the eAIP, and I'm not sure for the rest and I am unsure if we do have the permissions to add them.

merspieler commented 3 years ago

Australia
Qatar Have also some available.