search

leits / MeetingBar

🇺🇦 Your meetings at your fingertips in the macOS menu bar
https://meetingbar.app
Apache License 2.0
4.54k stars 203 forks source link

Bug: MeetingBar consistently disappearing from the menu bar #684

Closed annaderengowski closed 4 months ago

annaderengowski commented 9 months ago

macOS version

14.1.1

MeetingBar version

4.7

Installation source

AppStore

Calendars provider

Google Calendar

Bug description

I recently stopped getting notifications 1 minute before meetings, and noticed MeetingBar was missing from my menu bar. When I start MeetingBar from spotlight, it returns to the menu bar, but then disappears shortly after. I haven't yet figured out if there is a pattern to when it gets removed from the menu bar.

Reproduction steps

No response

Expected behavior

No response

Screenshots/screen recordings

No response

Additional context

No response

jvacek commented 9 months ago

Do you have a mac with a notch? It could be "hiding" behind the notch because of MacOS behaviour. If that's the case, you can shorten the length of the event title in settings.

annaderengowski commented 9 months ago

Do you have a mac with a notch? It could be "hiding" behind the notch because of MacOS behaviour. If that's the case, you can shorten the length of the event title in settings.

I do have a Mac with a notch, but this isn't the issue. MeetingBar isn't hidden, the app just stops running. I'm not getting meeting notifications when this happens. I significantly pared down the items showing in the menu bar, viewed the menu bar on an external monitor--MeetingBar doesn't appear until I re-open the app via Spotlight.

nitrocode commented 8 months ago

I have the same issue. I want to change the settings and the only way I can do it is by creating a false meeting in 5 minutes, then changing the setting, and then deleting the false meeting from my calendar.

osx m1 version 14.4.1

Usually the meeting bar info is here and does not have an icon for some reason.

image

muzirian commented 7 months ago

I have the same issue, on 16in M1 pro with notch running sonoma. Meeting bar is running in background, launching again makes no difference. Clicking on the notch shows nothing. But just noticed google drive has similar behavior and launching drive again opens the menu from under the notch. But launching meeting bar isnt opening the menu.

louisiscoding commented 6 months ago

So annoying

albertmonzo commented 5 months ago

Exact same issue, M1 Pro 16", Sonoma 14.5, installed via app download (not brew). When I first installed I thought it wasn't working at all, only figured it out when I saw the suggestion above of creating a fake meeting in 5 mins to force the tray item to show, then I was able to open the preferences and configure the app for the first time. Still, after the fake meeting was finished it disappeared again

jtron9k commented 5 months ago

Same issue for me as well. 14" M1 Pro, 32GB Ram, Sonoma 14.5. FWIW InYourFace had the exact same issue this morning, so after some searching I found out about MeetingBar to try it and am having this same issue. The fact another meeting notification app that lives in the menu bar is having the same issue is interesting.

nitrocode commented 5 months ago

I noticed something odd when upgrading meetingbar. It got unsynced from google and I was able to see the icon all the time in my meeting bar. I was very happy about this.

I did not know I was no longer logged into my google calendar until I noticed I wasn't getting the fullscreen notifications. Once I logged into my google calendar, the icon hid itself.

If I quit the meetingbar app and start it again. The icon pops up for a second in the tray which allows me to open the settings and then disappears. What's also weird, is that it appears next to the icon for flameshot, and then both the meeting bar and flameshot icons disappear.

When I quit meetingbar, the flameshot icon reappears.

Flameshot is installed globally /Applications/flameshot.app MeetingBar is installed locally /Users/user/Applications/MeetingBar.app

Unsure if that has anything to do with this.

CK-Ward commented 5 months ago

Same issue here. MeetingBar works great when i have an external monitor, but otherwise it disappears, probably because the length is too long for the compact sidebar.

sikander441 commented 5 months ago

Facing similar issue, I am not seeing Meetingbar in the menu bar at all, no matter how many times I try to launch.

Apple M3 Max running on Sonoma 14.5

bravely commented 4 months ago

Question for folks- do you have "No Icon" set for the meeting?

Screenshot 2024-06-27 at 9 05 36 AM

If you do, the app disappearing might be because when the app started up it didn't have today's events.

rarandall commented 4 months ago

The bar was only appearing for me on external monitors due to the laptop monitor (14in MBP M1) being too narrow. I got the bar to reappear by entering setting from external monitor meetingbar, adjusting the title length to 10 characters (Preferences -> Appearance -> Title)

leits commented 4 months ago

Hi folks! Thanks for the reports. Unfortunately, it's not a bug and there's nothing I can do about it.

The status bar is fully managed by macOS. So, if you don't have enough space in your status bar, macOS will hide all the items that don't fit. When you restart the app, macOS can remove some other items to fit the new item. It's just a macOS behavior and can't be changed from the app side.

I recommend using apps like Dozer, Bartender, or similar to clean up your status bar.

You can also change the Appearance settings for the MeetingBar to take up more space. If it is not currently displayed in the status bar, use this link to open the settings: meetingbar://preferences

duplicate of: https://github.com/leits/MeetingBar/issues/710, https://github.com/leits/MeetingBar/issues/561, https://github.com/leits/MeetingBar/issues/613

edmundcraske2-nhs commented 4 months ago

@leits It might be that sometimes it's behaving as you state - but there's definitely some other issue meaning that MeetingBar is not running after a while for some people (like me) - as I stop getting notifications also.

jtoy commented 4 months ago

FYI, I ran into the exact same issue and its fixed after following this thread. I suggest this info be added all over the app, in the FAQ, README, etc. I hunted for a while to find this and only found it because I searched closed issues here. The whole point of the app is to show calendars in the menu bar, so if there is a big potential reason why it may not work, then tit would be good to let others know! Basically the starting experience for anyone on a 14 inch maacbook pro is "it doesn't work"

afucher commented 4 months ago

Also, could have a configuration based on the size of the screen to show or not the title? I use external monitors and works perfectly, today I have to work only in my Mac and it started to not show. Solved with this thread, opening the settings and removing the title so it fits in the menu bar. I can open a new issue for this suggestion, if it makes sense.

nitrocode commented 3 months ago

This helped me by hiding icons I didn't need https://github.com/dwarvesf/hidden

GitHub
GitHub - dwarvesf/hidden: An ultra-light MacOS utility that helps hide menu bar icons
An ultra-light MacOS utility that helps hide menu bar icons - dwarvesf/hidden
jvacek commented 3 months ago

@leits It might be that sometimes it's behaving as you state - but there's definitely some other issue meaning that MeetingBar is not running after a while for some people (like me) - as I stop getting notifications also.

Possibly related to this? https://github.com/leits/MeetingBar/issues/656