Vorbis ripping does not work and gives error

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. Default install selecting both Vorbis and mp3 does not rip vobris files
2. Gives errors on voirbis changed the quality of voribs to -q 10
3. Still will not rib vobirs

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?

1) What version of rubyripper are you using? 0.5.4 On what operating
system? Ubuntu x64 8.10
2) Are you using the gtk2 or the commandline interface? GTK2
3) Is the problem gone with the default settings? NO problem existed even
if I uninstall and delete the .rubyripper direcotry and reinstall If so,
please attach your settings file ($HOME/.rubyripper/settings).

This is the setting file

req_matches_all=2
naming_various=%f/%a (%y) %b/%n - %va - %t
vorbissettings=-q 10
flacsettings=--best -V
cd=#<Disc:0x7f9b8d26a220>
edit=false
freedb=true
naming_normal=%f/%a (%y) %b/%n - %t
max_tries=5
wav=false
gain=album
req_matches_errors=2
editor=gedit
username=anonymous
verbose=true
maxThreads=0
mp3=true
normalize=false
first_hit=true
cdrom=/dev/cdrom
create_cue=false
site=http://freedb2.org:80/~cddb/cddb.cgi
playlist=true
other=false
no_log=false
filemanager=nautilus --no-desktop
hostname=my_secret.com
eject=true
instance=main
debug=true
naming_image=%f/%a (%y) %b/%a - %b (%y)
basedir=~/Music/Compressed/
othersettings=
mp3settings=--preset insane
image=false
rippersettings=
offset=0
vorbis=true
flac=false

PLease note:Typing at the command line

marcin@C2QL64:~$ oggenc -v
oggenc from vorbis-tools 1.2.0 

So I'm guessing everything I need is installed:

Please provide any additional information below.

This is a log file after ripping  from rubyripper.  The issue with unknown
CD is not a problem as it is a really rare CD and therefore not in the
database yet.
This log is created by Rubyripper, version 0.5.4
Website: http://code.google.com/p/rubyripper

Cdrom player used to rip:
TSSTcorp CDDVDW SH-S203S SB00
Cdrom offset used: 0

Ripper used: cdparanoia 
Matches required for all chunks: 2
Matches required for erroneous chunks: 2

Codec(s) used:
-vorbis -> -q 10 (oggenc from vorbis-tools 1.2.0)
-mp3    -> --preset insane
(LAME 64bits version 3.98 (http://www.mp3dev.org/)

CDDB INFO

Artist  = Unknown
Album   = Unknown
Year    = 0
Genre   = Unknown
Tracks  = 16

01 - Track 1
02 - Track 2
03 - Track 3
04 - Track 4
05 - Track 5
06 - Track 6
07 - Track 7
08 - Track 8
09 - Track 9
10 - Track 10
11 - Track 11
12 - Track 12
13 - Track 13
14 - Track 14
15 - Track 15
16 - Track 16

STATUS

Starting to rip track 1, trial #1
Starting to rip track 1, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 2387cfdf688b60b6d0adc294b57f36ff

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 1!
Starting to rip track 2, trial #1
Starting to rip track 2, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 51dc5316b779ffdbdf1458d852d26e23

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 2!
Starting to rip track 3, trial #1
Starting to rip track 3, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: f8886b351e07e43ed2a6bc3609ed81c4

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 3!
Starting to rip track 4, trial #1
Starting to rip track 4, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 7991df38af95fb8be66392ca383d0b5b

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 4!
Starting to rip track 5, trial #1
Starting to rip track 5, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 4c15b28eaa5d1337e549554ee0206c02

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 5!
Starting to rip track 6, trial #1
Starting to rip track 6, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: de859b9bbdaf7ed2900dd68d3401bd61

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 6!
Starting to rip track 7, trial #1
Starting to rip track 7, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: d18da5439b87ae26e92b3360c4c58db4

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 7!
Starting to rip track 8, trial #1
Starting to rip track 8, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: ed02ca3177762b7915b39be995a22346

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 8!
Starting to rip track 9, trial #1
Starting to rip track 9, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: f005dc0d35edd83a05856dca477abcc4

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 9!
Starting to rip track 10, trial #1
Starting to rip track 10, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: fc7f7c6712332e3a479c4568a0753493

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 10!
Starting to rip track 11, trial #1
Starting to rip track 11, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 38cc38d60880ab3c3da69b869933de64

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 11!
Starting to rip track 12, trial #1
Starting to rip track 12, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 1d0cb4beb047c47d285e86533b739493

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 12!
Starting to rip track 13, trial #1
Starting to rip track 13, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 18dd70c65d6bb2d7abc52de85c75d8c2

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 13!
Starting to rip track 14, trial #1
Starting to rip track 14, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 476c6dca0a503e008962b7b02a76549e

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 14!
Starting to rip track 15, trial #1
Starting to rip track 15, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 59d5e8da9cfbae529c45e80762bcda5e

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 15!
Starting to rip track 16, trial #1
Starting to rip track 16, trial #2
Analyzing files for mismatching chunks
Every chunk matched 2 times :)
MD5 sum: 23953a58b0ba182f0f37e2ae2da1dc6d

WARNING: Encoding to vorbis exited with an error with track 16!

WARNING: ENCODING ERRORS WERE DETECTED

RIPPING SUMMARY

All chunks were tried to match at least 2 times.
None of the tracks gave any problems

Original issue reported on code.google.com by marcinp...@gmail.com on 14 Dec 2008 at 7:26

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

This should be a defect not an enhancment issue but I canont figure out how to 
change
that in the issue report page.

Original comment by marcinp...@gmail.com on 14 Dec 2008 at 7:28

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

Also please note that I changed the voribus quality setting to -q 10.  But It 
does
not work with the default as well.

Original comment by marcinp...@gmail.com on 14 Dec 2008 at 7:29

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

I'll look into it. Thanks for the detailed bug report.

Original comment by rubyripp...@gmail.com on 16 Dec 2008 at 7:05

Changed state: Accepted
Added labels: Type-Defect
Removed labels: Type-Enhancement

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

I also had this problem and was able to solve it by removing the "-p 4" 
parameter in
the call of oggenc in rr_lib.rb. I do not know what this parameter is intended 
to do.
At least the two versions of oggenc I regularly use (OggEnc v1.0.2 and OggEnc 
v1.0.2
aoTuV beta 4.51)  do not know this parameter.

The attached diff removes the parameter and makes oggenc working for me with 
rubyripper.

One general question: Would it not be better when only really needed parameters
(e.g., setting the tag values) are hard-coded in rrlib?
Additional parameters (such as -p 4 whatever it is intended to do or 
--id3v2-only for
lame) IMHO should be defined by the user in the codec configuration. This would 
avoid
such errors like this one, and the user would have more flexibility (e.g., 
allow also
id3v1 tags for mp3).

Original comment by peter...@yahoo.de on 25 Dec 2008 at 2:16

Attachments:

remove_p4_oggparam.diff

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

I'm also experiencing the same error.

In reply to peter's comment on "-p 4":

I'm not sure what "-p 4" is being used for but after checking "man oggenc" I 
found this:

       -P, --name-replace=s
              Replace  characters removed by --name-remove with the characters
              specified. If this string  is  shorter  than  the  --name-remove
              list,  or  is  not  specified,  the  extra  characters  are just
              removed. The default settings for this option, and the -X option
              above,  are  platform specific (and chosen to ensure legal file‐
              names are generated for each platform).

I'm not sure if this would be the same as "-p" since the one I found from the 
man
page is uppercase but, just the same, I thought I should mention it.

Original comment by user6035...@spamcorptastic.com on 29 Dec 2008 at 10:34

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

I don't think it is the same because the oggenc's options are case-sensitive. My
oggenc version knows -P but does not know -p.

Original comment by peter...@yahoo.de on 31 Dec 2008 at 2:49

GoogleCodeExporter commented 9 years ago

The -p option is already removed on 12 november 2008. Closing the issue.

Original comment by rubyripp...@gmail.com on 15 Jan 2009 at 8:11

Changed state: Fixed

leoshaw / rubyripper

Vorbis ripping does not work and gives error #263