search

lexibank / abvdoceanic

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
5 stars 2 forks source link

Reran inventories #40

Closed antipodite closed 2 years ago

antipodite commented 2 years ago

@maryewal @angela-mc @SimonGreenhill I re-ran the generated inventories now the ABVD data has been updated and the Malekula profiles are fixed. Attached the inventory counts for all of Oceanic and Malekula to this issue for easy viewing. Numbers make sense?

https://share.eva.mpg.de/index.php/s/X6zsJeZxWjS6TFL -> All Oceanic https://share.eva.mpg.de/index.php/s/NeYQxKPXRJecPMB -> Malekula

Note to myself on how to use my own script >_<: cldfbench abvdoceanic.inventories --family ocea1241 --output output/inventories.tsv cldfbench abvdoceanic.inventories --family mala1539 --output output/malekula.tsv

SimonGreenhill commented 2 years ago

Thanks @antipodite, I think the next step is to look at the distribution here -- what's the average inventory size and does it make sense for POc or Malekula, what are the outliers with massive or tiny inventories and do they make sense. It would also be good to get some independent verification of these (e.g. compare to inventories in phoible?)

antipodite commented 2 years ago

Okay, I’ll make some numbers and crosscheck NewCaledonia with my own database. Phoible’s coverage for Oceanic is extremely patchy so unlikely to be of much use. We can do what Mattis did originally again, map the inventory sizes and then the experts in the respective areas can eyeball it and see if it makes sense.

maryewal commented 2 years ago

Thanks, Isaac! And, yes, please, I'd like to see a map of inventory sizes. That would be helpful.

antipodite commented 2 years ago

cool I'll sus it by monday

antipodite commented 2 years ago

@maryewal I just rebuilt the interactive map. git pull the latest version of the repo and open plots/map.html in your web browser. A tree diagram of mean inventory sizes at each branching node is on the way

maryewal commented 2 years ago

@antipodite - thanks. It looks way more sensible at first glance. Still a few high numbers in Malekula, but not nearly as many. Polynesia looks right too. I'll have a closer look and we can see what everyone thinks at the meeting on Thursday too. Sound good to you timewise @angela-mc ?

SimonGreenhill commented 2 years ago

comparison