lh3 / minigraph

Sequence-to-graph mapper and graph generator
https://lh3.github.io/minigraph
MIT License
411 stars 38 forks source link

lchain_rmq assertion fail introduced between 0.15-r426 and 0.15-r434-dirty #55

Closed ASLeonard closed 2 years ago

ASLeonard commented 2 years ago

I was mapping a subset of nanopore reads to a subset of a gfa, and everything worked fine under my previous minigraph version (0.15-r426) but then repeatedly failed an assertion in the latest version (0.15-r434-dirty) from the same command minigraph -t 2 -xlr --vc unitigs.gfa nanopore.fq.gz

error was

minigraph: lchain.c:363: mg_lchain_rmq: Assertion `max_j < 0 || (a[max_j].x < a[i].x && (int32_t)a[max_j].y < (int32_t)a[i].y)' failed.
Aborted (core dumped)

Same code segfaults at 011f4a2, and crashes at 94289c8 with the following

[kfree] The end of a free block enters the allocated block.
Aborted (core dumped)

So the assertion error seems to appear at 0c9086b.

lh3 commented 2 years ago

Thank you! Is it possible to share me with your data? I don't see the crash on my data. I had a look at code and recent changes but it is not immediately clear to me what could go wrong. When running minigraph, you may use

make asan=1
minigraph --dbg-kalloc --dbg-qname -t1

asan=1 and --dbg-kalloc helps to expose memory bugs. --dbg-qname prints query name. -t1 uses one thread. With these settings, you may be able to catch the read that breaks minigraph.

BTW, the current github HEAD has features backported from minimap2-2.24.

ASLeonard commented 2 years ago

The kalloc flag should be --no-kalloc, but the output was

QR  f2b6a9cc-eb94-4075-8db2-f6ff580557e4    0   91405
QR  48d7d91a-eeb5-4163-a6dc-931e631f4a5c    1   11718
minigraph: lchain.c:363: mg_lchain_rmq: Assertion `max_j < 0 || (a[max_j].x < a[i].x && (int32_t)a[max_j].y < (int32_t)a[i].y)' failed.
Aborted

The gfa and reads should be accessible here.

lh3 commented 2 years ago

Thanks a lot for this example. I believe I have fixed it.

ASLeonard commented 2 years ago

Yep that fixed it, runs smoothly now. Thanks!