Article classification specific to a journal field

Maelplaine commented 5 years ago

Problem / Motivation

WHO librarian? Citation database provider?
WHEN & WHERE in the article page but probably in downstream deliveries as well
WHAT a industry-specific keyword group
WHY to provide search filters and listings both inside the journal and from external databases

Proposed solution

Provide a list of keywords, organized in group, in the footer of the article page. The keywords don’t link to anything else yet.

Tasks

[ ] Article schema must accept some keyword groups and some items in those groups
[ ] Journal renders keyword groups on the article page

Clarification needed and assumptions

Is this a keyword group that is different from other keyword groups like research organisms, categories and tags? Or is it a different instance of the same pattern?

Technical notes

IJM is using the JEL classification which is used on article in economics journals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JEL_classification_codes
The typesetter classifies this as no different than a keyword group provided by the author: https://github.com/microsimulation/ijm-xml/blob/master/ijm-00666.xml#L2273-L2281
It may be styled or treated differently thanks to its kwd-group-type.

User interface / Wireframes

Not identical but could be similar to:

IJM JEL tafs

thewilkybarkid commented 5 years ago

Don't think there's anything to do here, it's already supported.

But:

It may be styled or treated differently thanks to its kwd-group-type.

Not sure what this means.

Maelplaine commented 5 years ago

@thewilkybarkid Yes that makes sense it will be included in the XML

Not sure what this means.

That's the XML tag for the article classification name. For example, "Research Organism" for eLife or JEL Classification for IJM

thewilkybarkid commented 5 years ago

That's the XML tag for the article classification name. For example, "Research Organism" for eLife or JEL Classification for IJM

@kwd-group-type is an attribute (ie for machines). We've implemented using the <title> element (which contains a human-readable form) or certain @kwd-group-type values (currently author-keywords and research-organism).

If there's an expectation about being 'styled or treated differently', that needs clarifying/specifying.

/cc @Melissa37

Melissa37 commented 5 years ago

For a MVP I don't think we need to try and link this to the taxonomy or anything for machine reading purposes. IJM has had them hidden in PDFs so far and if they want to invest in this additional piece then that's something for development by them.

Does that answer the question?

Unless you are asking whether they need a separate section with a header? I think not, again for MVP.

Hope I understand! M

thewilkybarkid commented 5 years ago

Yep, I read this as there's nothing to do so can close. (IJM can already include their 'JEL classification' as long as they include a <title>.)

libero / publisher