libre-tube / LibreTube

An alternative frontend for YouTube, for Android.
https://libretube.dev
GNU General Public License v3.0
8.47k stars 443 forks source link

[FEATURE] Google Account Sign in. #64

Closed Killercat103 closed 2 years ago

Killercat103 commented 2 years ago

Optional ability to sign in with your Google accounts. I know it may sound contradictory to the ibtebtions of the app. However, I think having the features you would get would attract a larger user base who wants to improve their privacy by removing client side trackers instead of the official app.

Maybe add a warning which says logging into Google will compromise their privacy.

lilcheti commented 2 years ago

We were adding import subscription from youtube account just like how newpipe does it

Killercat103 commented 2 years ago

We were adding import subscription from youtube account just like how newpipe does it

Well I wasn't talking about importing but actaually using your Google account. As much as I value privacy it's hard giving up recommended content because the populare videos are in most cases garbage. There's also the ability to comment which I would guess some people value. I know using an unofficial client wont help much when you're logged in. However, I still think small steps in the right direction would be beneficial. At least users of Libretube won't be affected by Googles Firebase Analytics client side.

IceDBorn commented 2 years ago

@Killercat103 You just don't get the goal of this project, this is not a Vanced clone and it won't turn into one.

Killercat103 commented 2 years ago

@IceDBorn I never wanted Libretube to be a Vanced clone. If i did, I would have mentioned advanced adblock or sponsorblock. My problem is that I'm quite frankly addicted to the recommendations of youtube but I can't find any clients which are open-source or does not contain client side trackers on top of the tracking Youtube has server side.

IceDBorn commented 2 years ago

@Killercat103 Actually, they will be implementing these at some point, the google login is out of the question though. The whole point of this project is to have a de-googled youtube experience as close as possible to the original experience.

Killercat103 commented 2 years ago

I can't mark this as not going to be implemented so I'll just close it. :/

lilcheti commented 2 years ago

We could do a LibreTube extended version that add these stuff too for the average users

Killercat103 commented 2 years ago

We could do a LibreTube extended version that add these stuff too for the average users

If you could that would be awesome! Thank you!

lilcheti commented 2 years ago

We could try if google won't come for us tho :)

nyabinary commented 1 year ago

Would be good lmao (I pay for premium in YouTube so it would be pretty nice to take advantage of that in some way)

NiffirgkcaJ commented 4 months ago

This looks better than most open-source clients of YouTube, and it's such a shame that it doesn't support Google accounts. MicroG could help, but I'm not sure.