jamaljsr
commented
11 months ago I just tested this on regtest and was able to confirm that circular rebalance payments are reflected in the stats and CSV export.
The way Terminal detects a circular rebalance is by matching the payment hash and amount of invoices/payments. If it finds a match then it considers the payment a rebalance.
For example, the payment hash in the screenshot above is 8d4cdc296f3302c9eeb52ccdc31add903bbd54a8679c8ba45fa2d755da6b26f6.
Here's my output for `lncli listinvoices`:
``` { "invoices": [ { "memo": "", "r_preimage": "30b626b0976493179f718cc47276e67cf53d5d82a700f22ade35c2e7decf9cc3", "r_hash": "8d4cdc296f3302c9eeb52ccdc31add903bbd54a8679c8ba45fa2d755da6b26f6", "value": "10000", "value_msat": "10000000", "settled": true, "creation_date": "1690813668", "settle_date": "1690813669", "payment_request": "lnbcrt100u1pjv038ypp534xdc2t0xvpvnm449nxuxxkajqam649gv7wghfzl5tt4tkntymmqdqqcqzzsxqyz5vqsp5yspsjnrzl390wjk295qzdfzhl5ehnz8jxut6fv3nurrv07crmgvs9qyyssqr3hnx2a6rcaqqgj4xztugvw6w0ztecwnnvqj3ffezdfmxlamelkytxwsplcjy7hnll8qmlc3v8m8ea6zj3zw7lh34r2d5jlqptuqwxcphkfreh", "description_hash": null, "expiry": "86400", "fallback_addr": "", "cltv_expiry": "80", "route_hints": [ ], "private": false, "add_index": "1", "settle_index": "1", "amt_paid": "10000000", "amt_paid_sat": "10000", "amt_paid_msat": "10000000", "state": "SETTLED", "htlcs": [ { "chan_id": "286972534915072", "htlc_index": "0", "amt_msat": "10000000", "accept_height": 302, "accept_time": "1690813669", "resolve_time": "1690813669", "expiry_height": 385, "state": "SETTLED", "custom_records": { }, "mpp_total_amt_msat": "10000000", "amp": null } ], "features": { "9": { "name": "tlv-onion", "is_required": false, "is_known": true }, "14": { "name": "payment-addr", "is_required": true, "is_known": true }, "17": { "name": "multi-path-payments", "is_required": false, "is_known": true } }, "is_keysend": false, "payment_addr": "2403094c62fc4af74aca2d0026a457fd337988f23717a4b233e0c6c7fb03da19", "is_amp": false, "amp_invoice_state": { } } ], "last_index_offset": "1", "first_index_offset": "1" } ```Here's the output for `lncli listpayments`:
``` { "payments": [ { "payment_hash": "8d4cdc296f3302c9eeb52ccdc31add903bbd54a8679c8ba45fa2d755da6b26f6", "value": "10000", "creation_date": "1690813668", "fee": "3", "payment_preimage": "30b626b0976493179f718cc47276e67cf53d5d82a700f22ade35c2e7decf9cc3", "value_sat": "10000", "value_msat": "10000000", "payment_request": "lnbcrt100u1pjv038ypp534xdc2t0xvpvnm449nxuxxkajqam649gv7wghfzl5tt4tkntymmqdqqcqzzsxqyz5vqsp5yspsjnrzl390wjk295qzdfzhl5ehnz8jxut6fv3nurrv07crmgvs9qyyssqr3hnx2a6rcaqqgj4xztugvw6w0ztecwnnvqj3ffezdfmxlamelkytxwsplcjy7hnll8qmlc3v8m8ea6zj3zw7lh34r2d5jlqptuqwxcphkfreh", "status": "SUCCEEDED", "fee_sat": "3", "fee_msat": "3030", "creation_time_ns": "1690813668905749420", "htlcs": [ { "attempt_id": "1", "status": "SUCCEEDED", "route": { "total_time_lock": 625, "total_fees": "3", "total_amt": "10003", "hops": [ { "chan_id": "313360813981696", "chan_capacity": "2000000", "amt_to_forward": "10002", "fee": "1", "expiry": 545, "amt_to_forward_msat": "10002020", "fee_msat": "1010", "pub_key": "03dd7fb67f7706dbe340f74e77a89fe08cf0a6cb12d594439d1adf56507c6ea18a", "tlv_payload": true, "mpp_record": null, "amp_record": null, "custom_records": { }, "metadata": null }, { "chan_id": "260584255848448", "chan_capacity": "16000000", "amt_to_forward": "10001", "fee": "1", "expiry": 465, "amt_to_forward_msat": "10001010", "fee_msat": "1010", "pub_key": "0319138cf382c8440ee967a1a63bc045d41137813c85f15c43bf1d9c1cb1f1d6ef", "tlv_payload": true, "mpp_record": null, "amp_record": null, "custom_records": { }, "metadata": null }, { "chan_id": "227598907015168", "chan_capacity": "16000000", "amt_to_forward": "10000", "fee": "1", "expiry": 385, "amt_to_forward_msat": "10000000", "fee_msat": "1010", "pub_key": "0203c741d1009fd324d91ecc480dcf98f1379a3faa7e0331b6081220c856da592a", "tlv_payload": true, "mpp_record": null, "amp_record": null, "custom_records": { }, "metadata": null }, { "chan_id": "286972534915072", "chan_capacity": "16000000", "amt_to_forward": "10000", "fee": "0", "expiry": 385, "amt_to_forward_msat": "10000000", "fee_msat": "0", "pub_key": "03e4dd278502245b2121535a5613854b9474069480d8c7e8248851ca4fa04608fa", "tlv_payload": true, "mpp_record": { "payment_addr": "2403094c62fc4af74aca2d0026a457fd337988f23717a4b233e0c6c7fb03da19", "total_amt_msat": "10000000" }, "amp_record": null, "custom_records": { }, "metadata": null } ], "total_fees_msat": "3030", "total_amt_msat": "10003030" }, "attempt_time_ns": "1690813668921111920", "resolve_time_ns": "1690813669317513004", "failure": null, "preimage": "30b626b0976493179f718cc47276e67cf53d5d82a700f22ade35c2e7decf9cc3" } ], "payment_index": "1", "failure_reason": "FAILURE_REASON_NONE" } ], "first_index_offset": "1", "last_index_offset": "1", "total_num_payments": "0" } ```You can see that the amounts match and the invoice's r_hash is the same as the payment's payment_hash. So this payment gets classified as a rebalance instead of a normal off-chain payment.
Can you check your invoice and payment for the rebalance that you performed to see if these also match on your node?
dekdynamics
In the Lightning Terminal Web UI, sats spent on rebalancing are no longer included in the overall stats on Home landing page, or in the P&L file.
I know I have completed rebalances today, and earlier this week, and I can see that lnd knows about them with
bos accounting paymentsThis is on the latest lnd 0.16.4 and litd 0.10.4 (--lnd-mode=remote).
Regards, The Wall