linked-art / linked.art

Development of a specification for linked data in museums, using existing ontologies and frameworks to build usable, understandable APIs
https://linked.art/
Other
91 stars 14 forks source link

Name of an object given in inscription on part #359

Open azaroth42 opened 4 years ago

azaroth42 commented 4 years ago

From Rijksmuseum data mapping exercise...

Names of objects can be inscribed on some identifiable part of them, such as the back or frame of a painting. The text of the name is thus carried_by the part of the object. The API division of the model has parts as separate documents, and there is no way to refer to arbitrary Name nodes.

Possible solutions:

(Thanks to @edwardanderson for this)

azaroth42 commented 4 years ago

Discussion in call on 2020-10-07: Allow carried_by on the Name, as it is a linguistic object as well as an appellation. (Would also work with Identifier, as carried_by is for Symbolic Object, of which Linguistic Object is a descendent)

azaroth42 commented 6 months ago

Propose defer to 1.1

azaroth42 commented 5 months ago

Related to #348

azaroth42 commented 5 months ago

With #586 this becomes much easier. The AttributeAssignment can used_specific_object of the part that carries the name. It can in turn carry the LinguisticObject that contains the text of the name. Then the Name and the text are not the same thing ... but I think that's okay -- the text is the source of the name, not the name itself.

Not sure we need an entry in the model for it, but perhaps a cookbook recipe?