jblom
commented
9 years ago Hi Lyndon, thanks for putting both the TKK and RBB issue lists here in GH. I will check them out today.
Open lyndonnixon opened 9 years ago
jblom
commented
9 years ago Hi Lyndon, thanks for putting both the TKK and RBB issue lists here in GH. I will check them out today.
ART OBJECT
(1) I am missing the properties "type" and "creation location" which are also defined in http://www.linkedtv.eu/wiki/index.php/Creating_rich_descriptions_of_cultural_artefacts_out_of_a_TV_program#Vocabulary
(2) No class constraints are applied which is dangerous in terms of getting good enrichments as a result, e.g. I could say "period IS Ming Dynasty" but this doesnt actually give me any time period (one could assume the DBPedia URI always has the properties dbpprop:yearStart and dbpprop:yearEnd but this isn't certain. In fact for times DBPedia looks really bad, http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ming_dynasty is typed as a Place!) For the Europeana lookup I need to be able to convert the entity to a time period, so it would be good to try to ensure this is possible, e.g. also allow the editor to directly enter start and end dates. Likewise, creator isn't constrained to entities of type Person.
(3) The detected entities seem to me to be useful as values of the art object properties rather than the subjects of information cards. (the latter case is what I presume you want for "background") but I didn't find a way to make e.g. "19e eeuw" the value of the period property of my art object.
(4) I didnt see where I could add a thumbnail image for my art object (something, btw, which we could link to WP1's object redetection some time)
(5) Since this dimension is for all entities to be added to the video chapter rename as "About" in line with the LinkedCulture UI
(6) I am not sure if the URI of a created entity is stored in the Platform before I create at least one enrichment for it. Then I am not sure if the information card will work if the Player uses the URI to extract that information from the Editor Tool JSON.
(7) I see the information card data for the art object in the JSON so I am not sure why you want to save the values of the properties as the values of prov:wasDerivedFrom the annotation instead of just the Art Objects URI.
BACKGROUND
(8) For me, e.g. using the entity Franeker, I wasn't getting any suggested enrichments even though TVEnricher directly does give me many images and videos
(9) When no links are returned I can't manually add any links since "New" doesnt let me associate a new enrichment with an entity from the chapter
(10) New enrichments get displayed alongside curated entities, I don't think this is correct
(11) I'd like to inspect suggested enrichments before adding them to the chapter. Maybe a mouseover which shows metadata from the enrichment, as available, and/or a "preview" button which opens the enrichment link in a new tab?
(12) I didnt really get why the ET has start time and end time for enrichment links unless you want to highlight the links during video playback in the player - even then the highlighting should be tied IMHO to the entity occurring at that time in the video and thus only indirectly on the enrichments generated for that entity.
RELATED ART WORK
(13) TBD that we integrate an Europeana API wrapper here. Currently OK that editor can add manually links to Europeana records.
RELATED CHAPTER
(14) TBD since Solr is not working for TKK atm - issue for LinkedTV Platform