search

linuxboot / heads-wiki

Documentation for the Heads firmware project
85 stars 44 forks source link

Strange FAQ answer: Why use ancient Thinkpads instead of modern Macbooks #147

Closed jonathancross closed 5 months ago

jonathancross commented 7 months ago

https://github.com/linuxboot/heads-wiki/blob/master/About/FAQ.md#why-use-ancient-thinkpads-instead-of-modern-macbooks

This FAQ answer does not address the question:

The x230 Thinkpad has coreboot support, TPM, nice keyboards and are very cheap to experiment on. Newer Thinkpads contain Bootguard, a closed source security function implemented by Intel to prevent unsigned custom firmware, such as coreboot and heads, from being installed.

Specifically: it doesn't mention Macbooks, but rather talks about the x230 Thinkpad.

daringer commented 7 months ago

For me this reads like "macbook" is meant to be figuratively - representing any/most modern laptops, thus I don't think it should be explicitly mentioned...

tlaurion commented 6 months ago

https://osresearch.net/FAQ/#why-use-ancient-thinkpads-instead-of-modern-macbooks

So we want to replace MacBook by "newer platforms" and keep example of newer thinkpads being bootguard enabled and coreboot unsupported hardware as counter examples?

@daringer @jonathancross : thoughts/specific expectations on what should be there instead?

daringer commented 5 months ago

I would stick with my previous comment, essentially a macbook is used figuratively here and I think it is ok like that

jonathancross commented 5 months ago

I would just change the word "Macbook" to "Laptop". The two are not synonymous to me.