linuxmint / mint20-beta

BETA Bug Squah Rush
20 stars 8 forks source link

Gdebi lacking useful screens #86

Closed davidbannon closed 4 years ago

davidbannon commented 4 years ago

To quote release page - "Gdebi, the tool used to open and install .deb files was given a new user interface."

In fact, what appears to have happened is some very useful information has been removed from GDebi with no benefit.

As a developer, I encourage users to use gdebi and to look at the pages it presents before installing, but with the version of gdebi in Mint 20 we cannot easily see developer contact details, we cannot confirm the version number, we cannot even see the installed size. And we cannot see the linian output, of great interest to a developer and arguably an indication of how 'compliant' a package is with Debian rules.

Otherwise, great looking release, congratulations folks.

Davo

xenopeek commented 4 years ago

This isn't so much a beta bug as a feature request to add the Lintian output tab; the other information you say is missing is in fact shown. Noted as such. Previous version of GDebi on Linux Mint didn't have the Lintian output tab either. If you prefer GDebi with Lintian output tab you can install it on Linux Mint 20 with this command:

apt install gdebi/focal gdebi-core/focal

To revert to the Linux Mint 20 GDebi run:

apt install gdebi/ulyana gdebi-core/ulyana

Aside from the Lintian output tab the same information, as far as I can see, is shown in Linux Mint 20 GDebi version:

NikoKrause commented 4 years ago

gdebi

with the version of gdebi in Mint 20 we cannot easily see developer contact details, we cannot confirm the version number, we cannot even see the installed size.

We are blind?

davidbannon commented 4 years ago

Thanks xenopeek for your polite and helpful reply. I only looked at it for a few seconds before the VM I was testing in crashed, permanently. It was long enough to see things things were not where I expected them to be. And I was not inclined to build another VM if its going to become unusable when I alter (virtual) screen size.

I am not sure I would regard requesting Lintian output as a Feature Request, more a revert an unnecessary change request :-)

And thanks Niko, your comment makes it easy for me to walk away from Linux Mint with out thinking I did not give you a fair chance.

Davo

NikoKrause commented 4 years ago

Sorry I didn't meant to be rude. You just had seconds to look at it before your VM crashed. You probably missed the screenshot on the release page under the text you quoted: Screenshot_20200618_115653

davidbannon commented 4 years ago

No Niko, you were quite right to point out that I had not confirmed the details and I should have before posting. And I should not have taken a poke at you, I am sorry. I was having a bad day but that is absolutely no excuse !

Linux Mint is a great looking product, I sincerely wish Ubuntu put as much effort into its presentation.

Davo