search

linuxmint / mintbackup

The mintBackup Backup Tool
https://www.linuxmint.com
58 stars 44 forks source link

mintbackup and backup policy #78

Open MikeNavy opened 2 years ago

MikeNavy commented 2 years ago

Hi, 1) Mintbackup is a simple backup but suffers of a great defect: it is not a differential backup; it is well adapted to users with a small size home, but not adapted to users with a large size home; as an example, my home has a size of 260 GB; a backup of my home with mintbackup would take hours. Suggestion: change mintbackup to a differential backup (1st use: all the files are backed; next uses: only the files that have changed are backed). See an example of such a program with FreeFileSync, https://freefilesync.org/. 2) Backup policy is not clearly defined and explained in Linux Mint:

NB: Why backups on an external disk? in case of physical crash of system HDD or SSD backup will still be available.

3) Latest suggestion: add some repair tools on Mint Live session (partition making / repair / resizing; GRUB repair; boot sector repair...). The Mint install DVD or USB key would so become also a backup and repair tool. Regards, MN

mexsudo commented 2 years ago

On 10/6/21 6:13 AM, MikeNavy wrote:

Hi,

  1. Mintbackup is a simple backup but suffers of a great defect: it is not a differential backup; it is well adapted to users with a small size home, but not adapted to users with a large size home; as an example, my home has a size of 260 GB; a backup of my home with mintbackup would take hours. Suggestion: change mintbackup to a differential backup (1st use: all the files are backed; next uses: only the files that have changed are backed). See an example of such a program with FreeFileSync, https://freefilesync.org/ https://freefilesync.org/.

  2. Backup policy is not clearly defined and explained in Linux Mint:

    • Timeshift can make system snapshots, is a differential tool; it could also make user home files snapshots. It can be used to recover system crashes in most of cases, but not in all cases.
    • Mintbackup is presented as a user home backup; it could also make system files backup, though it does not backup hidden or empty directories (cache and config directories are not copied).
    • There is no system backup tool such as Foxclone or Clonezilla.
    • The default installation of Linux Mint creates one partition only for '/' and '/home', hampering system backup (as an example, my '/' + '/home' has a size of 272 GB; I can make system backup because '/' and '/home' are in two separate partitions, and the backup of my 12 GB'/' takes a few minutes only). Suggestion:
    • Change the default installation to separate '/' and '/home' partitions.
    • Add a system backup tool, such as Foxclone, https://www.foxclone.com/ https://www.foxclone.com/, available when running LinuxMint as a live session from DVD or USB key.
    • Make changes to mintbackup (differential backup, backup of all files and directories in user home) or replace it with a tool such as FreeFileSync.
    • Explain the backup policy: a) make a periodic global system backup ('/' partition) on an external disk, using the DVD or USB key in live session, making the backup on an external disk; periodicity: few (2 to 4) weeks. b) make a periodic differential system snapshot with Timeshift, from an installed session, making the snapshot on an external disk; periodicity: 2 or 3 days, or at each major change (kernel...); user keeps the two latest snapshots. c) make a periodic differential user home backup, from an installed session, making the backup on an external disk: periodicity: 2 or 3 days, or after each new important document / video / photos sets etc.
    • Explain the restore policy: a) after a system problem, attempt to restore system with Timeshift, if it can be launched; if it works: OK stop; if not, see below. b) after a system crash, or if Timeshift does not succeed in restoring system, boot on live DVD or live USB key and restore the system with the backup / restore tool (Foxclone, Clonezilla...). Then update the system with Timeshift using the latest working system snapshot. c) restore user home with the differential tool or with the file manager

NB: Why backups on an external disk? in case of physical crash of system HDD or SSD backup will still be available.

  1. Latest suggestion: add some repair tools on Mint Live session (partition making / repair / resizing; GRUB repair; boot sector repair...). The Mint install DVD or USB key would so become also a backup and repair tool. Regards, MN

I do appreciate your ideas and concern.

to me Mintbackup is crapware in it's current state. I don't expect your ideas will be appreciated or acted on if "xenopeek https://forums.linuxmint.com/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=62313" is more than just another user and admin of the forum. https://forums.linuxmint.com/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=354173

Best of luck

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/linuxmint/mintbackup/issues/78, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABXEJK3MTQ2S5Y4VCIPU473UFRDO3ANCNFSM5FOR2WWQ. Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1477376905?ct=notification-email&mt=8&pt=524675 or Android https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.github.android&referrer=utm_campaign%3Dnotification-email%26utm_medium%3Demail%26utm_source%3Dgithub.