Add-comment widget in sectionpage context lacks pro-con selector

liqd / adhocracy

Adhocracy is a policy drafting and decision making software for distributed groups and open institutions.

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0

150 stars 37 forks source link

Add-comment widget in sectionpage context lacks pro-con selector #899

Closed nidico closed 10 years ago

nidico commented 10 years ago

The add-comment widget in sectionpage comment overlays doesn't have pro/neutral/con elements.

The edit-comment widget at the same place doesn't lack this selector.

Other add-comment widgets don't lack this selector.

nidico commented 10 years ago

The removal of sentiment buttons in norms context (e.g. sectionpages) has been removed deliberately in eb352f267ea73d9aaa3e5b31412106511d9fbdab. If this is on purpose the actual bug is that the buttons aren't hidden from the edit form.

@xi: Any idea why this has been removed in the first place?

xi commented 10 years ago

@xi: Any idea why this has been removed in the first place?

I guess it is because you can not be in favor of or against a norm because a norm is not an expression of opinion. So I agree that the actual bug is that the buttons aren't hidden from the edit form.