lisamelton / other_video_transcoding

Other tools to transcode videos.
MIT License
555 stars 26 forks source link

Default Audio Selection #187

Closed briangoodman closed 1 year ago

briangoodman commented 1 year ago

In non-English DVDs the commentary track is sometimes the first audio track and is flagged as default. To ensure that the proper track is processed by the default config in other_video_transcoding, I use MKVtoolnix GUI to move the main track to first audio track and flag it as default.

Does other_video_transcoding select the main track using the default flag or the first audio track? In other words, do I need to both move the track and flag it as default.

Thanks,

Brian

lisamelton commented 1 year ago

@briangoodman From the --help output:

    --main-audio TRACK[=WIDTH]
                    select main audio track by number (default: 1)
                      with optional width (default: surround)

So, it's always the first audio track. It doesn't matter which track has the default flag set.

I hope that answers your question.

briangoodman commented 1 year ago

Don,

Thanks for the quick response.

I will continue to move the main track into first position using MKVToolnix GUI for the oddball DVDs as that is a better workflow for me.

Regards,

Brian

P.S. It's hard to understand why DVD producers put the commentary track in first position.