liske / needrestart

Restart daemons after library updates.
GNU General Public License v2.0
426 stars 67 forks source link

apply override_rc deterministically #280

Closed bugfood closed 8 months ago

bugfood commented 1 year ago

When applying conf.d overrides to enable restarts for services that already have matching entries in the default override_rc, we can use a form like:

$nrconf{override_rc}->{qr(^dbus)} = 1;
$nrconf{override_rc}->{qr(^getty@.+\.servic)} = 1;

For proper behavior, we need to provide a regex that is exactly the same as the one in the default override_rc; needrestart matches against regexes in order and stops on the first match. What if there is a typo, though? Note the "servic" typo in the example above; this is a valid regex, but it's not quite the same as the one in the default override_rc.

Currently, if there are two matching regexes, the one that takes effect is random, with a 50% probability for each. This is due to behavior in relatively modern perl. Perl versions >= 5.18 evaluate hashes in an order that randomly differs from run to run.

https://perldoc.perl.org/perl5180delta

To provide deterministic behavior, sort the keys first. That way, the first matching regex will always win, and the intended override will either always work or never work.

liske commented 8 months ago

Thank you for pointing out this issue! That non-deterministic behavior was not intentional.

(btw: it is possible to remove override_rc entries using delete)

bugfood commented 8 months ago

Thank you for applying this.