Milestone 2 Feedback

[alok-sm]

Leave the feedback as a comment below

[XRWei]

By team 15

I checked out the storyboards by Chen Liu. I really like the first lost and found idea. People lost their stuff all the time, not knowing who found it or where it was located. However, more confidentiality maybe needed. For example, someone found a phone, instead of posting the photo online, posting a few descriptive sentences would be better. The person looking for his phone can only get it back if he answered specific questions correct regarding features of that phone.

The second idea is also interesting. However I believe that it is similar to some existing app related to Pokemon go.

The first idea is obviously more interesting. I really like to see it implemented and it will certainly help people.

[dingqixin]

Team Chicas (15)

Thank you for all of your storyboards!

For Wenshuo Li's storyboard 1, because of the development of transportation and improvement of living quality, traveling will become one of the most popular ways of amusement in 21 century. Therefore, there is a heavy demand on traveling related app. In the storyboard, when the system asks the user which way the user wants to choose, the user only says "most fun". I think it is an abstract term and is a bit difficult to define, so the system needs a clear way to figure out how to implement the answers for users.

For Wenshuo Li's storyboard 2, it catches a big issue currently in UCSD. Lots of people are unable to find parking lots. I believe it has large potential customers. The main problem I think your team should worry about is to figure out how to keep track of the parking and leaving to provide a real time parking location assistance.

[jessicajyeung]

(Team Chicas) Yuxiao Fang Storyboard #1: This is a nice idea, but how would you able to know how many parking spots are left with in each parking lot? Will this be a hands-free app? Will this account for how far they need to walk?

Yuxiao Fang Storyboard #2: How would someone know the magnitude of traveling the distance to the Himalayas? from which point? When does it start recording the distance that is traveled by the user? You wouldn't want to give the false impression that if they can walk the distance to the Himalayas, that they can walk the Himalayas. I do like that it allows the user to visualized the distance traveled. Nice digital drawings!

[ReginaChangzhou]

(team Chicas) For Chen Liu's storyboards, I really like to the Ingress Idea. I am not familiar with Ingress, if no one had done that and it is technically allowed, this will be a good one. For the lost and found one, I cannot see a huge difference between your idea and the facebook lost and found group. The position component seems trivial to this idea.

[agao323]

Wenshuo Li Storyboard 2

• nice solution, but does not necessarily solve the problem
• nicely drawn

Chen Liu Storyboard 1

• cool problem, cool solution
• maybe include a more specific setting

Chen Liu Storyboard 2

• Clear problem, clear solution
• problem is extremely niche and is more of a one-time problem

[liawesomesaucer]

Feedback from Team ABG (16):

General

• Storyboards are generally pretty concise and don't contain too much descriptive text (most text comes from exclamations/thoughts of personas). However, the storyboards mostly get the thought across.
• Some problems (ie parking) have been done a lot in classes - I'd make sure to come up with a novel/polished solution if going this route. (I do like the user of conversational UI through Siri though, but it could be platform-agnostic)
• Most storyboards stop at the moment the problem is resolved, but could elaborate a bit more on user fulfillment/other indirect consequences/benefits of the storyboard's application.

Storyboard-specific

• Storyboard 1 (Yuxiao Fang 1)

  • This is a neat idea and solution, but I'm having trouble gathering how it works for multiple people, as if one parking spot is listed, is it first come first serve? Also there seems to be little incentive for people to give information on how many spots are available unless everyone has downloaded the app

• Storyboard 2 (Yuxiao Fang 2)

  • Definitely an interesting take on quantifying exercise through more human-digestable information rather than numbers. I like this slightly gamified idea; however the race remotely feature does seem a little tacked on at the end and could use more elaboration. I like this idea a lot.

• Storyboard 3 (Wenshuo Li 1)

  • How is storyboard "fun"-ness quantified? This is an interesting problem to solve and since it's a storyboard it's not necessary to hint at the problem, but how "fun"-ness is quantified may be a factor in how users make a decision
  • I love Big Sur