search

livecomsjournal / livecomsjournal.github.io

Content for policy/instructional pages of the Living Journal of Computational Molecular Science (LiveCoMS)
https://livecomsjournal.github.io
6 stars 15 forks source link

Suggestions for tutorial description #127

Closed mrshirts closed 6 years ago

mrshirts commented 6 years ago

A few proposed changes for the tutorial description.

dmzuckerman commented 6 years ago

Yes, looks good. I guess you don't need my review now that it's merged

hmayes commented 6 years ago

As discussed on the call: --for editorial board appointment terms (II.3.ii), change "one month" to "three months" --Add a bullet that the recording secretary will keep track of all appointment start and projected end dates I'll make a pull request to tidy those items up.

I still think that the COI rules are too stringent. I think that it will make getting reviewers and assigning editors unnecessarily difficult. I suggest removing the COI due to serving at the same institution, and reducing the waiting period from 48 to 36 months. While I understand that it is convenient to use the NSF standards here, there is much more concern when money is involved (and potentially coming to the same university) than one publication.

davidlmobley commented 6 years ago

I think the above comment belongs on #86 .

And I tend to agree that it's silly to restrict people who are at the same institution or might be, unless there is some reason they would have a conflict. Basically we just want to be making sure people tell us if there's any reason they might not, or might be perceived as not, giving a fair review so we can decide.