search

lizzieinvancouver / ospree

Budbreak review paper database
3 stars 0 forks source link

Email Title ideas to Ailene #259

Closed AileneKane closed 5 years ago

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

Below is a list of title ideas received so far (requirements are 96 chars including spaces (Science, 90 for Nature):

  1. Cold winters cue temperate trees, but more so in growth-chamber experiments (char: 75)

  2. Cold winters cue temperate trees, but more so in experiments (60)

  3. Cold winters cue temperate trees more than warmth and daylength, in experiments (79)

  4. Chilling cue temperate trees more than forcing and photoperiod, but only in experiments (87)

  5. Chilling dominates spring phenology in experiments but does not explain observed declining sensitivities with warming in Europe (127)

  6. Chilling dominates spring phenological responses across experiments (67)

  7. Chilling dominates spring phenological responses (48)

  8. Chilling dominates spring phenological responses in experiments and complicates forecasts in natural systems (108)

  9. Chilling dominates phenological responses to warming in experiments but not natural systems (90)

  10. Chilling dominates in experimental phenology research but not natural systems (78)

  11. Strong chilling, forcing and daylength cues are prevalent across woody species (78)

  12. Meta-analysis of phenological experiments shows strong chilling, forcing and daylength cues (across woody species) (112/92)

  13. Chilling, forcing and daylength underlie (spring) phenological responses to warming (across woody species) (103/78)

  14. Chilling drives spring phenology across experiments and complicates forecasting (79)

  15. Prevalence of chilling, forcing, and daylength cues in woody plant phenology complicates forecasts (with warming) (112/100)

  16. Chilling outweighs photoperiod and forcing cues for temperate trees in experiments, but not in natural systems (110)

  17. Chilling outweighs photoperiod and forcing cues for temperate trees in experiments (82)

  18. Chilling outweighs photoperiod and forcing cues for temperate trees (67)

lizzieinvancouver commented 5 years ago

@AileneKane We should be careful to not be too close to other titles (e.g., Laude 'Chilling outweighs photoperiod in preventing precocious spring development') so may want to google titles before we pick top ones.

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

Top contenders Chilling dominates phenological responses to warming in experiments but not natural systems (90) Chilling dominates spring phenological responses (48) Strong chilling, forcing and daylength cues are prevalent across woody species (78) Chilling drives spring phenology across experiments and complicates forecasting (79) Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses (49)

lizzieinvancouver commented 5 years ago

Counts of some phrases in titles of Nature/Science papers (ISI):

winter temperature* -- 6 but ONLY once were words published together (e.g., 'Mechanisms of Age-Dependent Response to Winter Temperature in Perennial Flowering of Arabis alpina')

chilling -- 16 but only TWO apply to plants I think ('GENETICALLY ENGINEERED ALTERATION IN THE CHILLING SENSITIVITY OF PLANTS' or 'PROTOPLASMIC STREAMING IN PLANTS SENSITIVE AND INSENSITIVE TO CHILLING TEMPERATURES')

forcing is published a lot and is mainly about climate forcing ... so another good reason not to use it.

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

Final contestants: Chilling dominates spring phenological responses (48)- won with a score of 9 Chilling drives spring phenology across experiments and complicates forecasting (79)- our score = 11 Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses (49)- our score = 10

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

Note: we realized that its unclear what the responses are to. to fix this, these would be: Chilling dominates spring phenological responses to warming (50) Chilling drives spring phenology across experiments and complicates forecasting (79) Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses to warming (51)

lizzieinvancouver commented 5 years ago

If we use responses' we may needto warming' or some other explanation of responses to what

lizzieinvancouver commented 5 years ago

@AileneKane Jonathan likes `Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses to warming' ... he says 'a lot more.'

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

@lizzieinvancouver thanks for getting his perspective! We can all mull it over and discuss again prior to submission

lizzieinvancouver commented 5 years ago

@AileneKane Another option ... 'Chilling temperatures dominate spring phenological responses to warming' though doesn't have the cool winter-spring contrast.

AileneKane commented 5 years ago

ok, @lizzieinvancouver @cchambe12 @dbuona @jsamaha @tsavas @dflynn-volpe A head to head vote: Please send me am email with your top choice of these two titles:

  1. Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses to warming
  2. Chilling dominates spring phenological responses to warming
AileneKane commented 5 years ago

@lizzieinvancouver @cchambe12 @dbuona @jsamaha @tsavas @dflynn-volpe FYI: the winnter is 1. Winter temperatures dominate spring phenological responses to warming