share best citations supporting that experimental growth chamber studies are the best way to disentangle chilling vs forcing

[AileneKane]

Perhaps basic plant phys text book or classic articles?

[AileneKane]

@lizzieinvancouver @cchambe12 @dbuona @MoralesCastilla you can add ideas below or to the reviewer response letter that I send you on Monday April 6!

[cchambe12]

@AileneKane I've been doing a lot of digging through my books. The best I have so far is Sakai and Larcher, 1987 (Frost Survival of Plants) they talk about cold acclimation a lot and chilling requirements along latitudinal gradients. They definitely talk about using growth chamber studies to disentangle chilling and photoperiod but still looking for chilling and forcing.

[cchambe12]

@AileneKane

This one is pretty good! It mostly focuses on chilling but from the 50s so pretty cool to see what they were thinking about back then! They talk about the importance of using experiments to distinguish between rest (endodormancy) versus quiescence (ecodormancy/budburst). They also understand it takes chilling for `rest' to be completed and forcing for budburst to occur.

@article{samish1954dormancy, title={Dormancy in woody plants}, author={Samish, RM}, journal={Annual Review of Plant Physiology}, volume={5}, number={1}, pages={183--204}, year={1954}, publisher={Annual Reviews 4139 El Camino Way, PO Box 10139, Palo Alto, CA 94303-0139, USA} }

[AileneKane]

@cchambe12 Thank you! These are great!

[lizzieinvancouver]

@cchambe12 Thank you! That one sounds great.

@AileneKane Yes, I think some of the old papers might work best with a few more current ones. In OSPREE I recommend Junttila & Hänninen 2012 (which says, "Bud dormancy is released by an exposure to chilling temperatures in late autumn and early winter (Worrall and Mergen 1967, Sarvas 1974, Leinonen 1996).") and Worrall & Mergen 1967 (mix of experiments and controlled environment). One that I think is quite good includes a literature review: Harrington et al. 2010 (see Fig 5, trying to separate out these two), I will send over email.

I think you could say something like, decades of work have relied on controlled environment experiments (CITES here and from Cat)---those that we use here---to estimate chilling requirements, and equally to robustly estimate photoperiod and forcing requirements (plenty of CITES for this in OSPREE).

[AileneKane]

@lizzieinvancouver Thank you for these suggestions!

[lizzieinvancouver]

Lizzie also suggested Bonhomme et al 2010.