search

lllyasviel / stable-diffusion-webui-forge

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
8.49k stars 830 forks source link

Dear "lllyasviel" Can you make your own "ComfyUI" repo please? #2072

Open ClothingAI opened 1 month ago

ClothingAI commented 1 month ago

Hello, your mode (flux1-dev-bnb-nf4-v2.safetensors) is really amazing, nothing matches it! When I try other ComfyUI workflows, and their flux modes, I usually end up with 24G VRAM USAGE of my card and the UI just stop working. For instance: image

When I try to use your mode with other workflows, I just meet so many errors: image

Furthermore lot of nodes do not even know about your model I suppose? Here: image

The wright type, had nothing that could work with your model...

OK then why don't I EXCLUSIVELY use Forge Webui? Because LOT of extenions are NOT present in webui forge. For instance "InstantID" Which is really amazing. And many other extensions.

Let's face it! There are less and less extensions on a1111/ Forge UI.

We need you "lllyasviel" to come to the ComfyUI side, and make it "GREAT" in your own way. Please. Can't we have both your genius with the genius of all missing extensions from comfy? Why is your genius "limited" to the limited number of extentions classic webui (such as forge and a1111) have?

Please come to ComfyUI and make it great! ComfyReForge.

HelloXiaoxi commented 1 month ago

李博士计划在近期更新Forge的ControlNet。我不希望他加入Comfy阵营（节点式的操作太不容易理解了，需要极强的逻辑能力），因为他的智慧和胸怀，让我这种显存不高的设计师也可以轻松使用。

ClothingAI commented 1 month ago

李博士计划在近期更新Forge的ControlNet。我不希望他加入Comfy阵营（节点式的操作太不容易理解了，需要极强的逻辑能力），因为他的智慧和胸怀，让我这种显存不高的设计师也可以轻松使用。

是的，但 Ilyas 会让 Comfy 变得易于使用。 Forge 的问题在于它没有 COmfy 拥有的所有工具。否则你必须创建一个“转换器”将 Comfy 节点转换为 Forge 扩展？但这会很复杂。

Arnaud3013 commented 1 month ago

Strange, i've just update comfyui and try Flux-dev-Q8_0.gguf (using extensions for that gguf), and comfyui adapt by himself offloading in RAM. Maybe you don't have enough RAM? I've inscreased virtual RAM in windows, on my ssd (nvme) and set like 60Go for swap like. Now i do not have any issues.

ClothingAI commented 1 month ago

Yeah I had something ill condigured now I realized to make it work. Apparently unet + t5 GGUF is even faster

Arnaud3013 commented 1 month ago

i've download t5 gguf, didn't work in forge yet. How faster (in comfyui?)? because t5 is a bit worse than fp16