[lldb] Core dump not able to resolve source locations nor loading debug symbols?

[borjamunozf]

Hello! Trying to debug a core dump that works with GDB and Vscode but it does not with lldb-dap / lldb.

• Working config with vscode - gdb

  {
    "name": "(gdb) Launch Core Dump",
    "type": "cppdbg",
    "request": "launch",
    "program": "/mnt/disk1/sad/bin/AsdfApp",
    "args": ["-g "],
    "stopAtEntry": false,
    "coreDumpPath": "${workspaceFolder}/coreDump",
    "sourceFileMap": {
        "/asdshell": "${workspaceFolder}",
    },
    "additionalSOLibSearchPath": "/mnt/disk1/asd/app/lib",
    "cwd": "${workspaceFolder}",
    "miDebuggerPath": "/usr/bin/gdb-multiarch",
    "MIMode": "gdb",
    "logging": {
      "engineLogging":"verbose",
      "trace": true,
      "traceResponse": true,
    },
  }

• Trying to mimick functionality with lldb-dap:

  
  {
    "name": "(lldb-dap) Launch Core Dump",
    "type": "lldb-dap",
    "request": "attach",
    "coreFile": "${workspaceFolder}/coreDump",
    "program": "/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/AsdfApp",
    "sourceMap": [
      ["/asdshell", "${workspaceFolder}"]
      ],
    "preRunCommands":[
      "target symbols add /mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasda.debug",
    ],
    "initCommands":[
      "settings set target.source-map /asdshell ${workspaceFolder}",
      "settings set target.exec-search-paths /mnt/disk1/asd/app/lib:${input:asdfSysPath}/sysroots/x86-asd-linux/",
    ],
    "internalConsoleOptions": "openOnFirstSessionStart"
  
  }

The warning message with loading target symbols from .debug:

Running preRunCommands:
(lldb) target symbols add /mnt/disk1/rcs/app/bin/DispApp.debug
symbol file '/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasddas.debug' has been added to '/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasd'
warning: (i386) /mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasdsda 0x000cfcbd: DW_AT_specification(0x000000000009349e) has no decl

Info from breakpoints:

breakpoint list --verbose
(lldb) breakpoint list --verbose
Current breakpoints:
1: file = '/asdshell/asd/Main/Whatever/Source/WhateverInit.cpp, line = 13, exact_match = 0

2: file = '/asdshell/asd/Main/Whatever/Source/WhateverInit.cpp', line = 98, exact_match = 0

If I try to put the breakpoint other file it shows:

warning: failed to set breakpoint site at 0xc8b5630 for breakpoint 3.1: error: elf-core does not support enabling breakpoints
warning: failed to set breakpoint site at 0xc8b56ce for breakpoint 3.2: error: elf-core does not support enabling breakpoints

Show source map:

settings show target.source-map
(lldb) settings show target.source-map
target.source-map (path-map) =
[0] "/asdshell" -> "/home/borjamf/workspace/asd_shell"

I'll be happy to provide any info! Thanks a lot.

[borjamunozf]

Probaby related to #63973

I guess there is no solution, we have to keep suffering cppdbg with gdb.

[llvmbot]

@llvm/issue-subscribers-lldb

Author: None (borjamunozf)

Hello! Trying to debug a core dump that works with GDB and Vscode but it does not with lldb-dap / lldb. - Working config with vscode - gdb ```json { "name": "(gdb) Launch Core Dump", "type": "cppdbg", "request": "launch", "program": "/mnt/disk1/sad/bin/AsdfApp", "args": ["-g "], "stopAtEntry": false, "coreDumpPath": "${workspaceFolder}/coreDump", "sourceFileMap": { "/asdshell": "${workspaceFolder}", }, "additionalSOLibSearchPath": "/mnt/disk1/asd/app/lib", "cwd": "${workspaceFolder}", "miDebuggerPath": "/usr/bin/gdb-multiarch", "MIMode": "gdb", "logging": { "engineLogging":"verbose", "trace": true, "traceResponse": true, }, } ``` - Trying to _mimick_ functionality with lldb-dap: ```json { "name": "(lldb-dap) Launch Core Dump", "type": "lldb-dap", "request": "attach", "coreFile": "${workspaceFolder}/coreDump", "program": "/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/AsdfApp", "sourceMap": [ ["/asdshell", "${workspaceFolder}"] ], "preRunCommands":[ "target symbols add /mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasda.debug", ], "initCommands":[ "settings set target.source-map /asdshell ${workspaceFolder}", "settings set target.exec-search-paths /mnt/disk1/asd/app/lib:${input:asdfSysPath}/sysroots/x86-asd-linux/", ], "internalConsoleOptions": "openOnFirstSessionStart" } ``` The warning message with loading target symbols from .debug: ``` Running preRunCommands: (lldb) target symbols add /mnt/disk1/rcs/app/bin/DispApp.debug symbol file '/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasddas.debug' has been added to '/mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasd' warning: (i386) /mnt/disk1/asd/app/bin/asdasdsda 0x000cfcbd: DW_AT_specification(0x000000000009349e) has no decl ``` Info from breakpoints: ``` breakpoint list --verbose (lldb) breakpoint list --verbose Current breakpoints: 1: file = '/asdshell/asd/Main/Whatever/Source/WhateverInit.cpp, line = 13, exact_match = 0 2: file = '/asdshell/asd/Main/Whatever/Source/WhateverInit.cpp', line = 98, exact_match = 0 ``` If I try to put the breakpoint other file it shows: ``` warning: failed to set breakpoint site at 0xc8b5630 for breakpoint 3.1: error: elf-core does not support enabling breakpoints warning: failed to set breakpoint site at 0xc8b56ce for breakpoint 3.2: error: elf-core does not support enabling breakpoints ``` Show source map: ``` settings show target.source-map (lldb) settings show target.source-map target.source-map (path-map) = [0] "/asdshell" -> "/home/borjamf/workspace/asd_shell" ```  I'll be happy to provide any info! Thanks a lot.

[vogelsgesang]

Seems to be a general lldb issue, not specific to lldb-dap

[jimingham]

It would be useful here to separate possible problems with core files from problems with symbols. To that end, can you run a process under lldb with the same executable and symbol files, and see if you see source information in places where with core files you weren't. The speculation from the other report you linked to was that this was lack of support for some gcc DWARF constructs. If that's what is going on, just loading the executable & symbol file into lldb and running source info -f some_source_file.c should also fail.

[jimingham]

The title threw me off a bit because "why would you want to set breakpoints in a core file"... And certainly you can't "hit" them since core files can't execute (at least on any system I know about).

[borjamunozf]

You're right about setting the breakpoints in the core dump, my fault. I mxied with other stuf I'm working on! With the title I was referring for not reaching breakpoint it was more to the core dump line or source code.

It would be useful here to separate possible problems with core files from problems with symbols. To that end, can you run a process under lldb with the same executable and symbol files, and see if you see source information in places where with core files you weren't. The speculation from the other report you linked to was that this was lack of support for some gcc DWARF constructs. If that's what is going on, just loading the executable & symbol file into lldb and running source info -f some_source_file.c should also fail.

So my issue, as whole, its:

• the core dump is not hitting or reaching anywhere as the GDB config one. I think the sourceMap it's not working properly, because it says Unknown Source File..,

Edited:

• Running LLDB command line versus GDB it shows the blatant difference for source code location (LLDB does not anything, GDB by default already shows where it tries or where it referes to, even we have to change the sourceMap accordingly)

  lldb 
  > settings set target.source-map /asdshell /mypath/whatever
  > settings set target.exec-search-paths /mnt/disk1/asd/lib:blablablalba/sysroots
  > target create --core /mypath/whatever/coreDump /mnt/disk1/app/bin/WhateverApp
  > bt all

gdb-multiarch /mnt/disk1/app/bin/WhateverApp coreDump
> bt