search

lo48576 / iri-string

String types for URIs/IRIs.
Apache License 2.0
15 stars 3 forks source link

`is_normalized_whatwg()` method is non-compliant to WHATWG spec #30

Closed lo48576 closed 2 years ago

lo48576 commented 2 years ago

When the authority is absent, the path is relative, and the path after RFC 3986 normalization result starts with //, then WHATWG URL Standard handles the path as "opaque" and does not touch it during normalization. However, the current iri-string crate does not support "opaque" paths. So, foo:.///bar is untouched by WHATWG URL Standard but is_normalized_whatwg() returns false for it.

Possibly I should not say or imply the normalization as compliant to "WHATWG URL Standard", and this method should have different name.

Related to #29.

lo48576 commented 2 years ago

Changing method name is breaking change, so at first the method should be deprecated and then removed in next major release.

lo48576 commented 2 years ago

Fixed by 07029b878436450fb09888f304969b897d2fd46c.