search

logicahealth / vha-kbs-knarts

VHA Knowledge-Based Systems clinical knowledge artifact content development program.
Apache License 2.0
7 stars 3 forks source link

Imaging section cardinality is not consistently coded. #129

Open linophth opened 6 years ago

linophth commented 6 years ago

https://github.com/preston/vha-kbs-knarts/blob/44bb353f460ce3502673efd2889a49b10c1df751/content/cardiology_catheterization/o30/CDSK_KRprt_SADT_O30CardCath.xml#L1755

White paper chapter 2, section 8. In the white paper every type of image data is plural, but you did not consistently code it that way in the XML.

a-dru-desai commented 6 years ago

@linophth - Linda, is this unique to this KNART or crosses to other KNARTs of the same type?

linophth commented 6 years ago

I don't recall other instances, but I have not reviewed that many KNARTs yet

WendelynB commented 6 years ago

The example shown indicates multiple which indicates plural.

a-dru-desai commented 6 years ago

@WendelynB Does this occur at every instance of imaging (per the title of the issue)?

linophth commented 6 years ago

No, it doesn't - that is my issue.

csp4z commented 6 years ago

Issue does not note where there is an issue. Not enough detail to evaluate.

linophth commented 6 years ago

In line 1755 of the XML you include a responseCardinality value of “multiple”, indicating that there may be multiple chest x-rays that need to be pulled. That seems like a reasonable assumption since the white paper calls for chest x-rays (plural). Whether that was really what was intended or not is up for discussion, but for now that is what is in the white paper and it makes sense to me to handle each item in the Imaging and Diagnostic Studies section, chapter 2 section 8, consistently. So, if we are going to make cardinality multiple for chest x-ray we should do the same for the other items listed in this section. If all the images and other studies linked to are multiple, then the interpretation reports need to be multiple as well because each study would have its own interpretation. In the XML we are talking about lines 1700 through 1787.

WendelynB commented 6 years ago

Technical Review_Use of response cardinality use for Images (chest x-rays)

preston commented 6 years ago

Triaging to backlog per current acceptance criteria.