loup99 / WtWSMS

A Migrational Era Mod for CK2
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/index.php?forums/when-the-world-stopped-making-sense-mod.876/
Other
45 stars 33 forks source link

Graphical issues and proposals #257

Open IhateTrains opened 7 years ago

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Please submit all graphical proposals/lacking/oddly displayed graphics in this issue.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

I will start. New image for Frankish Steel bookmark since the current one is a placeholder: pick_era_frankish_steel The guy is Clovis I.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

I will start. New image for Frankish Steel bookmark since the current one is a placeholder: image

Do note that the displayed bookmarks are also placeholders and may change. However, when it comes to this, I'm not hostile to using that picture, although it may fit more with the "cut" effect.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

OK, I submitted the cutout version in my current PR.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Proposal: unique picture for Scholae Palatinae creation event scholae_palatinae_proposal

loup99 commented 7 years ago

I'm not convinced by the need for it, but from where did you get it?

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

I think it's a modded Total War unit. I've also found an image of Byzantine emperor reviewing his troops: f10b871aae173bc3dc19ed103faead79

loup99 commented 7 years ago

We can't use Total War elements. As for the picture, those are Varangians.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

I know, but it's still more Roman-like than random battle scene.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

We could use this picture for excubitors, too.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

Not really in my view, neither of those would be portrayed like this.

TurtleShroom commented 7 years ago

I agree with Ihatetrains. The first picture would look good in the Mod. The second one is of the Varangarians, though, as indicated by the symbols on their shields. If we edit those symbols out, it might work.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

We can't use the first picture for copyright and modding rules reasons. No Total War-derived content. The only thing we could use is the base assets of that modder without any Total War elements , and with explicit permission.

Concerning the second, the whole imagery is about Viking Varangians, just editing out a CoA won't suffice.

TurtleShroom commented 7 years ago

Okay. That makes sense.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

In my view these legion pictures could maybe serve: ¨ image

image

image

Although note that these are reenactments and that we would need to use effects such as cut-out, as well as doing image editing.

TurtleShroom commented 7 years ago

Are they accurate reenactments, though? Most pictures of Legionaires and Roman soldiers that I see are based on the first century (mohawk helmet, rectangle shield, more bared skin, etc.), which is universally associated with Rome.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

Those were example samples. I believe the latest one on Commons was one on the 4th century or so.

TurtleShroom commented 7 years ago

Okay.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

We could also use the existing "legion marching" picture:

roman_legion_marching

loup99 commented 7 years ago

Good idea! Changing the CoA on that, if possible, is the best solution in my opinion.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

I'm not skilled enough to change the CoA/entire shields and keep the shades :( I can only do something like this: roman_legion_marching_chi_ro or this: roman_legion_marching_chi_ro_2

(maybe intense cutout would hide the lack of shades). Are these ones better than original?

loup99 commented 7 years ago

I'm on the fence, because it does create a contrast. The shields are also too large on the top one. Otherwise we can use the original, for a lack of a better option.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Proposal: revised flag of the Eastern Roman Empire Before: 2017-07-21 After: 2017-07-22 1

I made Chi-Rho a bit smaller and red a bit darker.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

Yeah, that is better!

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Needed: More fitting event picture for 2000th anniversary of the Gothic kingdom

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Some proposals from the existing files: royal_court.tga from the mod feast_attila.dds from the mod dancing_feast_wol.dds from vanilla Banquet_hall_Feast.dds from vanilla

loup99 commented 7 years ago

Having looked at them, I think feast_attila is quite a good fit. Do you have any preferences?

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

It also appeals to me. The vanilla feast pictures are good but are too commonly used.

loup99 commented 7 years ago

The Legendary Leader trait should be distinct from Guard Veteran, so that could be a potential improvement if anyone has suggestions.

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

2017-10-13 2

They are slightly different but yeah, not much :D

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Noted in my TODOs, but I still don't have any good idea on it

IhateTrains commented 7 years ago

Proposal: Chi-Rho flag for the Western Roman Empire I suggest giving the current red Chi-Rho version to e_wre and making a purple version for e_byzantium. Do you want a preview?

loup99 commented 7 years ago

I disagree. The Chi Roh was formed by Greek letters, and the current flag is a lot more styled. It also allows to distinguish the two.

IhateTrains commented 6 years ago

Needed: icon for Samaritan religion, as it is no longer just a Jewish heresy

loup99 commented 6 years ago

I realise that it should be possible to add an unique texture for the Bureaucratic government.

loup99 commented 6 years ago

Going to split off the "missing" religion icons into a separate issue.

IhateTrains commented 6 years ago

For the Bureaucratic government we could use the Imperial government icon.

loup99 commented 6 years ago

I don't see how that would be an improvement. I prefer the current icon.

IhateTrains commented 6 years ago

Sorry, I thought you were looking for the government icon replacement.

loup99 commented 6 years ago

Oh, yes, I realise it wasn't obvious from my post, sorry. What I meant are the special government ribbons and map icons for the government, not the government icon which we already have.

IhateTrains commented 6 years ago

What would be the color of the ribbons? Maybe purple?

loup99 commented 6 years ago

That could be one alternative, yes. Preferably not the same as any other government form to differentiate though.

IhateTrains commented 6 years ago

Proposal: new era image for the Little Augustus era image (the dude is Odoacer)

Advantages over the current one:

loup99 commented 6 years ago

What is the issue? That can be fixed separately no matter the picture used.

With regards to the proposal, since it clashes with the other ones in terms of graphics and has no real identification for the players (since we don't know exactly how Odoacer looked, although this has the merit of being the closest we can get) I'm personally sceptic. The current one is also "related" to the era in the sense that the player can identify, although naturally it could be improved.

dantaki commented 6 years ago

I am running 2.8.0 and there are missing portraits and I cannot click on the person to interact (declare war etc) example

loup99 commented 6 years ago

@dantaki This is not a place for bug reports, especially for old versions of the game. Please register your game and post in our sub-forum.

Darokrithia commented 6 years ago

@dantaki Thank you for the post btw. Also please include the save file when you post it on the sub-forum