loup99 / WtWSMS

A Migrational Era Mod for CK2
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/index.php?forums/when-the-world-stopped-making-sense-mod.876/
Other
45 stars 33 forks source link

The Franco-Visigothic Wars #426

Open Frag05 opened 5 years ago

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Visigothic_Wars

I know wikipedia isn't the best source but the lack of any events in the timeline surprises me, it deserves more than a simple map change from one year to another.

loup99 commented 5 years ago

That is far too much rail-roading for my taste. Syagrius will naturally espace if he loses his demesne, the participation is handled by sending troops or not, and dying in battle is done through vanilla events. We could change the death cause however. And on migration, what source do you base that upon?

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visigothic_Kingdom

Kingdom of Toulouse

"...Following a brief war with the Franks, Alaric was forced to put down a rebellion in Tarraconensis, probably caused by recent Visigoth immigration to Hispania due to pressure from the Franks..."

Visigothic settlements

"...and specially after the Battle of Vouille, many Goths and their federated peoples, such as the Vandals, Ostrogoths, and Sarmatians, moved to settle more freely under their kindred clans' rulers, the reiks, who received dukedom territories or comital offices as counts over smaller territories or key urban locations within the provinces of Hispania and in southwestern Gaul..."

loup99 commented 5 years ago

You said "around half of the population"?

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

Sounds absurd? An Arian population conquered by a Catholic ruler might for sure felt discomfort and decided to move. I now got curious about the visigoths around barcelona, didn't they mostly migrate to hispania after vouille?

IhateTrains commented 5 years ago

So "around half of the visigothic population" is just your guesses?

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

Yep, i could not get estimates, so a random number of counties affected are set?

loup99 commented 5 years ago

Yep, i could not get estimates, so a random number of counties affected are set?

Or as any other war, new rulers culture convert provinces through the random MTTH.

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

I don't like the consistency of MTTH for situations like these, getting the goths into hispania would take almost two centuries, the minimal MTTH is ~24 years (Steward 15+ and Depopulation 3), In real life the people moved on or stayed and got absorbed.

Plus: Theodoric the Great managed Visigothica from 511 to 526, due to Amalaric's infancy, making Theodoric a emperor and the Visi under his control is the closest approach i can see, 522-526 Amalaric was a adult but yet under Ostrogothic influence.

loup99 commented 5 years ago

Plus: Theodoric the Great managed Visigothica from 511 to 526, due to Amalaric's infancy, making Theodoric a emperor and the Visi under his control is the closest approach i can see, 522-526 Amalaric was a adult but yet under Ostrogothic influence.

No, they are a tributary.

Frag05 commented 5 years ago

In-game they are 100% independent.

loup99 commented 5 years ago

In-game they are 100% independent.

I confused the two, inside k_vandalica :

500.1.1={
    set_tribute_suzerain = { who = k_italy percentage = 0.25 }
}
523.1.1={
    holder = 94
    clear_tribute_suzerain = k_italy
}

I can look at the Visigoths to see why they are not a tributary.

IhateTrains commented 4 years ago

I can look at the Visigoths to see why they are not a tributary.

Solved in cbdfb29.