lov435 / SoftwareImprovement

A repository to house projects worked under the Software Improvement task.
1 stars 0 forks source link

Minor_2.1 Inconsistent threshold values described in the clustering algorithm #44

Closed lov435 closed 2 years ago

lov435 commented 2 years ago
  1. Clustering Algorithm (Section 3)

Section 3 mentions "More specifically, this algorithm considers whether to assign a Stack Overflow comment j to a cluster C by examining all previously assigned comments Ci in that cluster and treating the classifier's prediction weight, wij >= 0:5, as a vote for j." However, Section 5 denotes this under the graph cutting algorithm "We use a lower voting algorithm threshold of wij >= 0:4 for a positive vote". Shouldn't this two be the same weight? Also, if you use 0.4 as the weight, I suggest that this threshold value should be justified using proper and concrete empirical evidence in Section 5. Otherwise, this looks like an arbitrary threshold.

lov435 commented 2 years ago

Ready for review

damevski commented 2 years ago

Done