lp-wan / datamodel

use of yang to describe SCHC
1 stars 3 forks source link

Access control to part of Rules #18

Open MarinoMtz opened 1 year ago

MarinoMtz commented 1 year ago

Ana: In the leaf-ac-modify-compression-rule In no-change (0) Is it correct?: The rule cannot be modified or is it an element of the rule? In modify-existing-element (1) and add-remove-element: only the FID can be changed or also MO, TV, CDA, any part of the Rule?

LT: what may be not clear in the document, is that without any AC element, a rule cannot be read or write, with 0 it can be read but not modified. You have the possibility to add rules, then to add field descriptor and then modify elements. Ana: Yes, I think this is not clear, and we need to define which Rules or parts of the Rule are Readable, Writable, etc, This means the permission of each cell in your table and the permission of each Rule in your Context.

minaburo commented 1 year ago

I prepared some time ago an Excel file with the FIDs of IPv6/UDP/CoAP. The only fields that may change and need written permission are those CoAP options with Repeatable configuration. This may give input to change from static to synchronize... Did you see this file? I put it in attach.

Ana

On Wed, Jun 7, 2023 at 10:29 AM Marino Martinez @.***> wrote:

Ana: In the leaf-ac-modify-compression-rule In no-change (0) Is it correct?: The rule cannot be modified or is it an element of the rule? In modify-existing-element (1) and add-remove-element: only the FID can be changed or also MO, TV, CDA, any part of the Rule?

LT: what may be not clear in the document, is that without any AC element, a rule cannot be read or write, with 0 it can be read but not modified. You have the possibility to add rules, then to add field descriptor and then modify elements. Ana: Yes, I think this is not clear, and we need to define which Rules or parts of the Rule are Readable, Writable, etc, This means the permission of each cell in your table and the permission of each Rule in your Context.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/lp-wan/datamodel/issues/18, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AEFFDUSKZTM6O7KMZMIACU3XKA3V3ANCNFSM6AAAAAAY5QFW3M . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>