lpmorenoc / dssat-csm-os

DSSAT Cropping System Model
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Bring back the water stress factor for photosynthesis #46

Closed lpmorenoc closed 3 years ago

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

James suggested to bring back the effect of water stress on photosynthesis. Here some simulations before and after the change: Before Thailand image

Now Thailand image

Before Palmira: image

Now Palmira image

Before Quilichao image

Now Quilichao image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

If WFP does not have any effect when the volumetric water content is above 0.5 of the difference between field capacity and wilting point:

Palmira image

Quilichao image

If we also reduce the effect of WFG as we did for WFP: Palmira image

Quilichao image

the LAI is not affected enough: Palmira image

Quilichao image

LAI when WFG is restricting from field capacity while WFP when the water content is half: Palmira image

Quilichao image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

Nigeria (WFP=0.5, WFG=1): image

Nigeria (WFP=0.5, WFG=0.5): image

Quilichao (WFP=0.5, WFG=1): image

Quilichao (WFP=0.5, WFG=0.5): image

Thailand (WFP=0.5, WFG=1): image

Thailand (WFP=0.5, WFG=0.5): image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

Quilichao (CCQU8201) (WFP: 0.75, WFG: 1): image

image

Nigeria (IIIB8201) (WFP: 0.75, WFG: 1): image

image

Thailand (AGKK1502) (WFP: 0.75, WFG: 1): image

image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

I think I will keep WFP limit as 0.75 while WFG will maintain as 1. However, I need to review the reduction in the storage weight in Nigeria.

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

If there is not reallocation of assimilates in the Nigerian trial: image

It is mainly due to the high water stress values: image

If WFP is 0.5 still without reallocation: image

image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

Nigeria Increasing RUE with WFG=1 and WFP=0.5 (no reallocation): image

With 5% reallocation: image

Using WFG: 0.75 and WFP 0.5 (no reallocation): image

image

Quilichao Using WFG: 0.75 and WFP 0.5 (sensitivity to senescence 0.3): image

image

Increasing sensitivity to senescence due to water stress (0.5): image

If we use WFG: 0.5 and WFP: 0.5 and we increase the sensitivity to senescence more (0.7): image

lpmorenoc commented 3 years ago

Other experiments with WFP= 0.5 and WFG=0.75: Palmira (Colombia) image

Thailand: image

Quilichao (Colombia) image

Quilichao (Colombia) image