lukso-network / LIPs

LUKSO Improvement Proposals. Repository for the LUKSO Blockchain Improvement Proposals (LIPs) and LUKSO Standards Process (LSP).
100 stars 44 forks source link

Icon Request: icon-lyx #296

Closed CHEYCKIT closed 5 months ago

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Would like to to propose an official currency symbol to Lukso that would act as a shortened version for LYX and for LUKSO.

this is the symbol we should use for LUKSO, 𝕃 would be the alternate symbol for LYX

I think the Benzene works in some scenarios rather well when the page is zoomed however in other cases, when the page is small, an alternate symbol would improve readability drastically, 𝕃 is the community's choice (we've went ahead and used it in https://wandz.works/lend), as repeating LYX too much all over dapp pages clutters the feed

Use cases would be same as ETH Ξ :

Integration in FontAwesome would look like this: Build on <i class="fa fa-lukso" aria-hidden="true"></i> for ⏣ Build on <i class="fa fa-lyx" aria-hidden="true"></i> for 𝕃

Icon: image image

Unicode U+23E3, HTML entity code &#9187 Unicode U+1D543, HTML entity code &Lopf

frozeman commented 5 months ago

This is a nice idea. We should get a bit more attention to community on this.

Done: https://x.com/feindura/status/1802800679615901969?s=46&t=mHnUtZy2_NCtmF4oPK44eQ

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

⏣ (U+23E3) or ㆨ (U+31A8)

First one is cool, second one is more with L + Y + X

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

Would like to to propose an official currency symbol to Lukso that would act as a shortened version for LYX.

Ŀ this is the symbol we should use. I initially wanted to use one of the 3 the hexagons in unicode (⬣) but they are hard to read on small screens and for near-sighted people (like me lol) so they'll often look like circles.

I think the Latin Extended A Ŀ works rather well (we've went ahead and used it in https://wandz.works/orderbooks, as repeating LYX too much all over the website was cluttering the pages)

Use cases would be same as ETH Ξ :

  • IoT
  • DApps
  • Websites
  • UI/UX

Build on <i class="fa fa-lyx" aria-hidden="true"></i>

Icon: image

Unicode U+013F, HTML entity code &Lmidot

Made a poll on X: https://x.com/DWOPEs/status/1802855710205607984

⏣ (U+23E3) or ㆨ (U+31A8)

First one is really cool, second one is with a combo of L + Y + X

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

⏣ (U+23E3) or ㆨ (U+31A8)

First one is cool, second one is more with L + Y + X

1st one will have to pass image

2nd one is nice but has formatting issues since it's a japanese character image

So far those are the only contender valid imo, we can make a new poll for these two later on @frozeman

100 Ŀ 100 Ÿ

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Final Poll is here on X: https://x.com/DWOPEs/status/1803086212455936460?t=tJXqtJZZHIDB_Qiija6IEg&s=19

Go vote on the poll, this should be final

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Would like to to propose an official currency symbol to Lukso that would act as a shortened version for LYX.

this is the symbol we should use.

I think the Latin Extended A works rather well (we've went ahead and used it in https://wandz.works/orderbooks, as repeating LYX too much all over the website was cluttering the pages)

Use cases would be same as ETH Ξ :

  • IoT
  • DApps
  • Websites
  • UI/UX

Build on <i class="fa fa-lyx" aria-hidden="true"></i>

Icon: image

Unicode U+23E3, HTML entity code &#9187

Final Poll is here on X: https://x.com/DWOPEs/status/1803086212455936460?t=tJXqtJZZHIDB_Qiija6IEg&s=19

Edited to reflect the results of the poll. It'll be the benzene ring

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

@frozeman the community wants ⏣ after a vote (i think it's too close to SOL (◎) i personally would still keep Ŀ, can you make the final call?

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

Community is the way, it's not a centralized project decided by 1-2 person, if there is nothing more than tastes and colors, it owes to community right ?

@frozeman the community wants ⏣ after a vote (i think it's too close to SOL (◎) i personally would still keep Ŀ, can you make the final call?

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Community is the way, it's not a centralized project decided by 1-2 person, if there is nothing more than tastes and colors, it owes to community right ?

There is more than taste and colors though, if the symbol can be mistaken easily with another, it's fundamental problem for Dapps and consumers of said Dapps

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

Ok so my opinion is that Ŀ is even worst and a bad idea, it's the marketing logo of Linea ^^ at least the ring is just text, and doesn't define marketing usage like Ŀ is used by linea

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Option 1 L˙= Linea Marketing with no token Ŀ = LUKSO Dapps

Option 2 ⏣ = LUKSO Dapps ◎ = SOL Dapps

Ok so my opinion is that Ŀ is even worst and a bad idea, it's the marketing logo of Linea ^^ at least the ring is just text, and doesn't define marketing usage like Ŀ is used by linea

How is option 2 better than option 1? Please explain

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

Tbh Solana one is far from being the same than our ring, more bigger and rounder, while our logo is better recognizable, i'm not that shocked, while Linea is exact copy of marketing, I really don't like

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

Tbh Solana one is far from being the same than our ring, more bigger and rounder, while our logo is better recognizable, i'm not that shocked, while Linea is exact copy of marketing, I really don't like

Screenshot_20240619-131026_Kiwi_Browser (1).jpg

Am I using SOL ticker here or the LYX Benzene (trick question)

Please use a zoom to answer this

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

@oukira27 Turns out, there is a difference with the Linea Logo, that logo is actually (two characters, L+˙) as opposed to Ŀ That difference is on the same level as the Benzene Vs Sol, Except one is a top 10 valuation in web3 and the other has no valuation at all...

I need to hear from more developers on this, not on the community which just chose the "prettiest one"

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

@oukira27 how about θ (Theta) or 𝕃 ? as in

100 LYX = 100 θ 100 LYX = 100 𝕃

Thoughts?

oukira27 commented 5 months ago

@oukira27 how about θ (Theta) or 𝕃 ? as in

100 LYX = 100 θ 100 LYX = 100 𝕃

Thoughts?

I think 𝕃 is a good idea yeah ! Does it works well for dev side by using this one ? True it should be compatible for builders first, you're right

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

I think 𝕃 is a good idea yeah ! Does it works well for dev side by using this one ? True it should be compatible for builders first, you're right

After testing, yeah 𝕃 works rather well, just as much as θ, i've made a poll on it and it won https://x.com/DWOPEs/status/1803769735479251212

I'm moving towards 𝕃 as main symbol, for readability personally

CHEYCKIT commented 5 months ago

To conclude this, we end up with two symbols,

Unicode U+23E3, HTML entity code &#9187 Unicode U+1D543, HTML entity code &Lopf

image image

⏣ is the symbol we should use for LUKSO 𝕃 would be the alternate symbol used for LYX

They can be used interchangeably depending on your d-app needs, your format and how zoomed in/out your elements are on your page.