magefree / mage

Magic Another Game Engine
http://xmage.today
MIT License
1.91k stars 778 forks source link

Blind Obedience causes Xenagod to enter tapped #3515

Open MasN2 opened 7 years ago

MasN2 commented 7 years ago

No screen shot because Blind Obedience was destroyed afterwords. Xenagos was commander, if it changes anything.

emerald000 commented 7 years ago

Seeing how this is one of the most confusing interactions, here's how it should work according to the rules:

Yes, this is weird. This is because we need to predict a future event: Will Xenagos be a creature permanent or not? To do so, we check before it enters the battlefield (since it is a replacement effect) if our devotion to GR is 7+. If it is, Blind Obedience applies. If not, it doesn't apply.

MasN2 commented 7 years ago

The devotion was 3 including Xenagod, so I see no reason why it should enter tapped.

Zerrisx commented 4 years ago

Entered tapped with devotion of 4 without counting itself. Definitely a bug. image