search

magiclabs / magic-js

Magic browser/React Native JavaScript SDK is your entry-point to integrating passwordless authentication inside your application.
https://magic.link/docs/api-reference/client-side-sdks/web
Apache License 2.0
463 stars 86 forks source link

Wallet created through Magic SDK vs Fortmatic #475

Closed LuwkasLima closed 1 year ago

LuwkasLima commented 1 year ago

✅ Prerequisites

❓ Question

I've noticed that if I create a wallet using the same e-mail through Magic SDK (on my DApp) and through Fortmatic/Magic (OpenSea), 2 distinct wallets are created. Does that means each wallet will be exclusively attached to the DApp instead of been 1:1 to the e-mail address?

I was wondering if people minting NFTs on my DApp would be able to trade them on the secondary market places like OpenSea for instance?

🌎 Environment

Software Version(s)
magic-sdk
Browser
yarn
Operating System
ayv8er commented 1 year ago

@LuwkasLima Magic Auth apps are locally scoped to your application's publishable API key. End users wanting to access the same wallet would need to return to the app of the same Magic Auth publishable API key.

If you're looking for similar behavior in user scope as Fortmatic, consider Magic Connect. Magic Connect apps are globally scoped like Fortmatic. One end user can visit multiple Magic Connect applications and will always recall the same wallet.

LuwkasLima commented 1 year ago

Thx for the clarification @ayv8er. Happy to know that this is possible, although I see the limitations imposed by the Magic Connect that were not imposed for Magic Auth previously.