Things to check for Go Big papers [DRAFT] - Githubissues

maho3 / ltu-gobig

1 stars 0 forks source link

Things to check for Go Big papers [DRAFT] #20

Open maho3 opened 4 months ago

maho3 commented 4 months ago

Writing

[ ] Theory for each methodology

Nbody

[ ] Coverage of Pk at a single cosmology, for various solvers
[ ] Convergence as a function of hyperparameters
[ ] Make a plot of P(k) vs. quijote for each method

Halo biasing

[ ] CHARM differences between BorgPM and FastPM
[ ] Quantify differences in the accuracy of halo P(k) with/without RSDs. Maybe will need an additional correction or network
[ ] Implement PineTree?
[ ] For the models which do exist, plot a P(k) and HMF comparison as a placeholder

Galaxy-halo connection

[ ] HOD prior specification
[ ] HOD posterior inference
[ ] Compare constraints on 5-param and 10-param

Fiber collisions

[ ] Plot P(k) with/without fiber collisions

Mock Inference

[ ] Compare halo P(k) among available simulations, Quijote, Abacus, MTNG. In comoving and redshift-space.

Observational Paper

[ ] Plot 'Observational target' characterization

General checks

[ ] Write code to generate plots of all sims