maho3 / ltu-gobig

1 stars 0 forks source link

MTNG 3Gpc/h inference #25

Open maho3 opened 1 month ago

maho3 commented 1 month ago

This issue is solely to keep notes for analyzing 3 Gpc/h inference using MTNG 3 Gpc/h ground-truths.

Notebook: https://github.com/maho3/ltu-gobig/blob/run_experiments/experiments/mtnglike/inference_mtng.ipynb

maho3 commented 1 month ago

Configuration

Coverage

image

Notes

This is really bad likely because of many things:

maho3 commented 1 month ago

The reason for this ^ was that the MTNG simulation data was already masked in a conical lightcone. Specifically, it covered one octant of the sky. image

When we measured P(k) without the mask correction, this messed with the large-scale modes of the galaxy P(k), and removed the classic 'turnover' we expect of large-scale surveys.

Instead, I have taken this raw MTNG lightcone and rotated it to overlap with the NGC footprint. image

And then trimmed things down in the observational sample to only include the overlap. image

After redshift reweighting, this matches well: image

Now, the monopole P(k) looks closer to the observational sample image

Though, the MTNG cosmology + galaxy configuration here may not be ideal.