maho3 / ltu-ili

Robust ML in Astro
https://ltu-ili.readthedocs.io/en/latest/
45 stars 9 forks source link

Implement an emulator for the multipoles of the 2PCF #39

Closed axellapel closed 11 months ago

axellapel commented 1 year ago

We need a fast non-linear summary emulator from the Quijote suite of simulations to build benchmark comparisons for ILI techniques against standard MCMC analyses. We will at first emulate the monopole and quadrupole of the 2pt correlation function with fixed binning and redshift.

Notes:

EDIT: The first comment is misleading, the emulator aims at quickly estimating the summary for a given cosmology (mean value of the Gaussian likelihood) but not the covariance matrix.

modichirag commented 1 year ago

Question/clarification- Are you thinking of making an emulator as function of cosmology over Quijote simulations? To my understanding, standard MCMC analysis estimates covariance matrix at a fixed cosmology to also capture the cosmic variance due to different initial conditions, and afaik there is no cosmology dependence, is there?

axellapel commented 1 year ago

No no sure, sorry for the confusion, the comment is misleading. The multi-cosmology emulator is for a fast estimation of the mean in the standard Gaussian likelihood but won't indeed play a role in the estimation of the covariance matrix.

maho3 commented 11 months ago

@axellapel can we close this issue if its no longer under construction?

axellapel commented 11 months ago

Sure, we can reopen one whenever we need!