mainIine / foe-helfer-extension

FoE Helfer - Extension for chromium based browsers and Firefox ;-)
https://foe-helper.com
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
121 stars 181 forks source link

[Feature request] City Planner Simple Improvements #2574

Open MrPeteH opened 1 year ago

MrPeteH commented 1 year ago

(As it is, City Planner is almost worse than the built-in editor: harder to see categories, harder to know what an element is!)

Some simple (?) suggestions to make City Planner far more helpful. Suggested with an eye toward practical implementation:

  1. Thicken the color edges by 2-3 pixels (at least in storage), and have a color key available to show the categories of items.
  2. Mark the buildings that do/do-not require roads.
  3. Consider changes to the labeling: hide labels that say nothing (e.g. 1x1 roads say "G..." or "P..." which isn't helpful) while still keeping the mouseover info.
  4. Have at least two additional sorts/groupings available for stored items:
    • By category (current)
    • By Building Group (eg Statue of Honor + Road to Victory; all Celtic Forest buildings; Terracotta Vineyard buildings; etc)
    • By Aspect Ratio low-to-high or reverse (eg Animal Crossing (6 x 3 = 2.0 aspect) at the top, square things in the middle, Ferris wheel at the bottom)
  5. Consider sorting the Filter By-Size (it's random now), using apect ratio + size. (primary key aspect, secondary size)

NOTES: Building Groups has value because we always have to keep those in mind when arranging a city. Aspect ratio has value because we like placing narrow edges along roads, and like to group buildings by long side length.