mainIine / foe-helfer-extension

FoE Helfer - Extension for chromium based browsers and Firefox ;-)
https://foe-helper.com
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
121 stars 181 forks source link

[Feature request] Add Seed Vault to Statistics #2584

Open tedypm2000 opened 1 year ago

tedypm2000 commented 1 year ago

Hello, I see it's already been asked 2-3 times previously but the tickets seem to just be closed without any reply. Can you confirm if this is possible and under consideration or if we should stop asking?

Thank you and thank you for the extension.

outoftheline commented 1 year ago

the problem used to be that none of the devs had a seed vault, so we could not develop it due to no chance to test.

i built it some months ago... buuuuut: now, with auto-aid the rewards from seed vault are not seperate from any of the other rewards (blueprints, coins, any goods from truce tower, etc.) therefor it's really difficult to track it.

tedypm2000 commented 1 year ago

the problem used to be that none of the devs had a seed vault, so we could not develop it due to no chance to test.

i built it some months ago... buuuuut: now, with auto-aid the rewards from seed vault are not seperate from any of the other rewards (blueprints, coins, any goods from truce tower, etc.) therefor it's really difficult to track it.

Unless I'm missing something I believe it's an easy fix to just bunch them up together. Most people if not all will use/want the Seed Vault in the statistics tab mainly for the diamond drops. It's the only GB (or aid action for that matter) that drops diamonds (50 a piece/per 1 aid action trigger)

As for the goods, they are specifically your current age goods. Meaning regardless of the age of the player you're helping, they'll always be from your age (the goods Seed Vault gives) - as opposed to the Truce Tower which gives goods based on the age of the player you're helping, if I'm not mistaken.

Plus, you can distinguish (I assume?) the goods received from Truce Tower due to their amounts? Seed vault has fixed numbers of possible goods rewards per 1 aid. These are, if I recall correctly, 4, 6, 8, 12. The Wiki states chunks of 4 for sure, anyway. Truce tower gives 1 per aid, with a limited amount of aids. So you can just subtract your current-age-goods received rewards x whatever is the Truce tower max according to level, and you'll be left with those that came from Seed Vault.

Those who don't have a truce tower (like me) will find it even easier.

Just gave it a quick thought and outlined but ya, but it seems the difference/ambiguity when having Truce Tower + Seed Vault, reflected in the Statistics would be negligible, with regard to goods. I doubt people would care that much for others (coins, supplies, blueprints). Diamonds and goods are the focus.

Seed vault gives: Coins, Supplies, Only current age goods, Medals & Diamonds (no bps) Truce tower: 1 good x whatever attempts your tower level gives. i.e., lvl 50 gives 79 attempts, meaning you can get 79 current age goods if, presumably all you're aiding and triggering truce tower is your own age. That's obviously not gonna happen so just check the rewards, subtract x amount of non-current-age-good received, from the 79 total possible and you've almost narrowed it down. The difference remaining are truce tower current age goods aids and the rest are from the seed vault.

outoftheline commented 1 year ago

i have the truce tower, because i've been playing so long. built it when tomorrow era came out basically.

i have a lot of friends and guild mates in the same age as me (last one), so i might get a lot of goods from TT that can be mistaken for SV goods. really dont see an easy way to sort through the goods and say "this came from SV, this from TT".. they might not be the same amount a lot of the times, but they can be sometimes. it's always 20 says foe wiki, so 4 of each. i could work with %4 then, so the data should be correct most of the time. might give it a try some time.

still, players "rely" on the data, compare it, sometimes bug inno support when they think they found a bug via helper etc. so whatever i am doing needs to be correct.

tedypm2000 commented 1 year ago

i have the truce tower, because i've been playing so long. built it when tomorrow era came out basically.

i have a lot of friends and guild mates in the same age as me (last one), so i might get a lot of goods from TT that can be mistaken for SV goods. really dont see an easy way to sort through the goods and say "this came from SV, this from TT".. they might not be the same amount a lot of the times, but they can be sometimes. it's always 20 says foe wiki, so 4 of each. i could work with %4 then, so the data should be correct most of the time. might give it a try some time.

still, players "rely" on the data, compare it, sometimes bug inno support when they think they found a bug via helper etc. so whatever i am doing needs to be correct.

Not sure about 20 each time. Just aided 126 (friends list) and got 16x each good only. Sometimes it's 28, other times 12, 16 and just 4 each etc.

Isn't there like an identifier/variable in the backend that you can read and identifies the trigger/rewards pertaining to the seed vault mechanism?

On a side note, I'm thinking you could add the section to the statistics and for now just add the diamond tracking since that won't be an issue. Add a disclaimer or such to the section identifying as a work in progress / not 100% accurate data with regard to the rest and I'm guessing that would be awesome to most people who use/have it.

outoftheline commented 1 year ago

Not sure about 20 each time. Just aided 126 (friends list) and got 16x each good only. Sometimes it's 28, other times 12, 16 and just 4 each etc.

yeah, thats why it's 20 every time :D 4 of each.

Isn't there like an identifier/variable in the backend that you can read and identifies the trigger/rewards pertaining to the seed vault mechanism?

unfortunately no, the aid rewards are all in one big reward pile, not saying where they came from. that's the problem here.

Arcadioo commented 7 months ago

Just add the diamond statistics and everyone will be satisfied

tedypm2000 commented 4 months ago

Hello. Still no progress on this, at least on the Diamonds part? That's pretty much what everyone would need, and since it's the only one giving diamonds in the big reward pile when using aid all buttons, should be straight-forward?