mainIine / foe-helfer-extension

FoE Helfer - Extension for chromium based browsers and Firefox ;-)
https://foe-helper.com
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
119 stars 181 forks source link

Suggestion: Neighborhood combat memory #2666

Closed arlininger closed 6 months ago

arlininger commented 10 months ago

Include a window for combat with a neighbor that will show you the results of your previous battle with that neighbor. This would essentially be the equivalent of taking meticulous notes on each combat engagement and recalling those notes when you are about to attack a neighbor again. No predictions, no auto-combat.

Minimum viable product: Was the previous combat a win or a loss.

Goal: What army did the neighbor have defending last time?

Ideal: What army did I bring? What army did they bring? Which units were killed? Was it auto-combat?

outoftheline commented 10 months ago

We used to have a feature called PvP Activity a few years back, but had to remove it as per InnoGames request

arlininger commented 10 months ago

I don't know what that features entailed, but I recall reading something about a feature that made combat suggestions. I'm thinking something that would be equivalent to taking really good notes. If even that is going to far for InnoGames, no worries.

GeniePower commented 9 months ago

We used to have a feature called PvP Activity a few years back, but had to remove it as per InnoGames request

I completely understood the issues with showing the collections which gave the ability for the attacker to avoid decoys (i.e. TF set to 5 min supplies instead of FP/Goods). All the info that you're able to write down shouldn't be an issue. I had a love/hate relationship with Plunder helper all the time it was available

outoftheline commented 6 months ago

Sorry, we will not bring back features that can give an "unfair advantage" to some. Saving neighbours armies will most likely be considered unfair.