Open germsvel opened 6 years ago
Transaction.ex
and its counterparts belong in a different umbrella-app altogether?Relates to #566
@hayesgm
Are you suggesting that Transaction.ex and its counterparts belong in a different umbrella-app altogether
No, I hope we don't move the implementations out to separate umbrella apps.
I think this issue was a little confused and didn't have a clear suggestion. It stemmed from the fact that our ethereum common tests are mixed in with our regular tests, and that can seem strange sometimes.
So maybe a better aim of this issue would be to figure out whether or not we want to have all ethereum common tests live in a single place (just the tests not the implementations) or whether we prefer just keeping them as they are. I think it could provide some clarity on what are ethereum common tests and what are mana
's own tests.
All this being said, I think after having more knowledge of the code base and if #566 actually happens, I think they could stay where they are. In which case, we could close this issue altogether.
Currently we have the common StateTests and TransactionTests inside the
blockchain
app:We should probably move those out of the blockchain app since they aren't the blockchain tests.
We also have ethereum common
BlockchainTests
andVMTests
. Those reside within their respective apps:I'm not sure where we should move the common tests. Clearly, not all of them match our apps 1-1 (e.g. we do not have an
apps/transaction
. Because of this, it may make sense to have all the ethereum common tests in a single place (even the blockchain and evm ones). If that does not sound like a good idea, we should at the very least move the StateTests and TransactionTests outside of the blockchain app.