luisy-eng
commented
6 days ago auditedBalanceCollection.js Code Review
Architecture:
- [A1] Single Responsibility Principle: The
AuditedBalanceCollectionclass adheres to SRP by focusing solely on the audited balance data, including defining, updating, removing, publishing, and subscribing to data. - [A2] Layered Architecture: The class effectively separates the data schema and collection management logic, utilizing
BaseCollectionto manage database interactions. - [A5] Use of Collections: The use of a SimpleSchema with MongoDB collections follows the best practices for data schema validation and collection setup in a Meteor-based application.
- [A7] Naming Conventions: Methods like
define,update,removeIt, andpublishfollow clear naming conventions that reflect their responsibilities. - [A8] Scalability: The structure supports adding new fields or modifying the schema as the project requirements change, making it scalable for future data structure adjustments.
Design:
- [D1] Consistent Naming: The method and variable names are consistent and descriptive, reflecting their purpose (e.g.,
subscribeAuditedBalance). - [D2] Error Handling: While there is some validation (e.g., checking if values are numbers in
update), the class could benefit from more detailed error handling and user feedback mechanisms, especially duringupdateandremoveItoperations. - [D4] Data Validation: The schema uses SimpleSchema for input validation, ensuring that the types of data stored in the collection match the expected schema.
- [D7] Maintainability: The use of methods and modularity in this class supports maintainability. However, adding comments to describe the purpose of each method would improve clarity.
JavaScript:
- [JS2] Code Readability: The code is generally readable, with well-structured methods. However, more inline comments could further enhance readability.
- [JS3] ES6+ Features: Uses modern JavaScript features like
const,let, destructuring withObject.entries(), and arrow functions, which align with best practices. - [JS6] Consistency: Consistent coding style is used throughout, which aids in readability and maintainability.
- [JS9] Avoiding Unnecessary Computation: The
updatemethod only updates fields with numerical values, which is a good practice to avoid unnecessary database operations.
AuditedBalanceSchemaInput.jsx Code Review
Architecture:
- [A3] Modularization: If the file includes logic for input handling and form UI, ensure these are separated into different functions or components to enhance modularity.
- [A5] Use of Components: The component should leverage React's ability to break down complex forms into smaller, reusable pieces.
- [A7] Naming Conventions: The component's name, props, and functions should clearly indicate their purpose, such as
handleInputChange,saveForm, etc. - [A9] Dependency Management: If any third-party libraries are used for form handling or validation, ensure they are appropriately managed and do not add unnecessary complexity.
Design:
- [D1] Consistent Naming: Ensure that the names of inputs, handlers, and state variables are consistent and descriptive, making the code easier to understand.
- [D2] Error Handling: Implement error handling for form validation and submission to ensure user input is correctly validated before being saved.
- [D6] User Feedback: Ensure the component provides clear feedback to the user for any invalid inputs or successful submissions.
- [D9] Reusability: If the component contains repetitive input fields, consider breaking them into smaller, reusable components to maintain DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) principles.
JavaScript:
- [JS1] Use of Const/Let: Use
constfor variables that are not reassigned andletwhere reassignment is needed. - [JS4] Destructuring: Destructure props and state to simplify the code and make it more readable.
- [JS5] Event Handling: Ensure event handlers like
onChangeoronSubmitare properly managed and bound to avoid unnecessary re-renders. - [JS7] Handling Async Code: If the component makes async calls (e.g., for saving data), ensure proper use of
async/awaitto manage promises and errors.
React:
- [R1] Functional Components: Prefer functional components over class components, using React hooks like
useStateanduseEffectfor managing state and lifecycle methods. - [R2] Hooks Usage: If the component uses hooks, ensure they are used correctly. For example,
useEffectshould handle side effects and dependencies properly. - [R5] JSX Structure: Ensure the JSX is well-organized, with conditional rendering handled gracefully to maintain a clean UI.
- [R7] Component State Management: Manage state effectively to avoid unnecessary re-renders, especially in forms with multiple input fields.
TannerBerry
Sydnee-You
RomaMalasarte
blakewatanabe
cjochim
juncell-venzon
cash-baker
Overview
The focus for this code review will be centered around the auditedBalanceCollection.js and AuditedBalanceSchemaInput.jsx.
Please pay attention too:
Review Branch
review-6
Files to review
Checklists
Due date
10/21/24
For more information
The review process is documented at: http://courses.ics.hawaii.edu/ics414s21/morea/review/reading-idpm-review.html