Parity with maki1 for iD

bhousel commented 8 years ago

This is more FYI, and not necessarily a to-do. I chatted with @natslaughter today, here is a generated list of icons that iD is using from maki1 that are not in maki2:

[x] ~~camera~~ -> attraction
[x] ~~chemist~~ -> pharmacy
[x] city #307
[x] emergency-telephone #306
[x] ~~industrial #308~~ -> industry
[x] logging #309
[x] marker-stroked #310
[x] mobile-phone #311
[x] park-alt1 #315
[x] scooter #263
[x] slaughterhouse #312
[x] ~~toilets~~ -> toilet
[x] town #313
[x] village #314

Also I did notice some icons have changed semantically and we would need to change how we use them:

[x] barrier (we were using prison for all kinds of gate-like things, barriers, fences, etc) #316
[x] fence (similar to barrier although specifically for fence-like barriers) #324
[x] entrance-alt1 (we were using it for entrances to buildings / parking garages, not just escalators) #317

Also if we're doing requests, we could use

[x] defibrillator (will cover AED / defibrillator) #104 #318
[x] recycling #152
[x] landuse ("generic" land-use) #319
[x] natural/landcover (like "landuse" but only natural things) #328
[x] horse-riding #304

Thanks!! Love the new maki2 icons! 👍

cc @kepta cc @nickidlugash

aparlato commented 7 years ago

I made a couple of minor changes to clarify the needs from the above list. Specifically I changed prison to gate and made the note reference that we were using prison for this previously. I am also making minor changes to meet our naming convention.

nickidlugash commented 7 years ago

@aparlato @natslaughter should we consider this request for a horse-riding icon as part of this push?

aparlato commented 7 years ago

^ just started this (horse riding icon) and will work on it tomorrow. I'm in favor of adding it to the mix.

natslaughter commented 7 years ago

@bhousel Here is where the icons stand as of today. @samanpwbb, @nickidlugash, @aparlato and I met yesterday and came up with a plan to finish this up and incorporate them into the Maki catalogue next Monday or Tuesday.

Icon	11 x 11	15 x 15
Logging
Barrier
Park-alt1
Entrance-alt1
Landuse
Mobile-phone
Emergency-phone
City
Town
Village
Defibrillator (bolt)
Defibrillator (ekg)
Slaughterhouse
Horse-riding

natslaughter commented 7 years ago

@bhousel Thanks for letting us know about the 'natural/landcover' icon need. I'm going to suggest we hold off for this round of icons, since we are finished with the icons and are merging them into Maki today. Let's treat this as an individual icon request #328.

aparlato commented 7 years ago

Closing #270

Released all these icons :+1:

bhousel commented 7 years ago

Thank you for all your work on this!

bhousel commented 7 years ago

cc @ajithranka who is working on the maki migration for iD.

mapbox / maki

Parity with maki1 for iD #270