search

marcsowen / homebridge-homematicip

Homematic IP plugin for homebridge
Apache License 2.0
76 stars 18 forks source link

HmiP-FBL chaotic behaviour in automations #279

Open fr3akst3r opened 2 years ago

fr3akst3r commented 2 years ago

Hi there,

I am experiencing unexpected behaviour of multiple HmIP-FBLs wenn using f.e. a HomeKit automation for closing all jalousies after leaving home. Behaviour is especially seen when to be closed jalousies are completely open. They just move a bit down and go up again. HmIP-BROLLs are behaving just fine.

marcsowen commented 2 years ago

Could you enable the debug log output and send the logs while the automation is closing the jalousies? I don't own this actuator so I cannot really reproduce it myself unfortunately.

fr3akst3r commented 2 years ago

After having found out how to do that I will reply with a log. Thanks for your reply!

EDIT 30.01.2022: I am still not sure how to export a debug log. Is there a short tutorial somewhere out in the web? Didn't manage to find anything...

sidthekid87 commented 1 year ago

Hi there,

I have the same issue. I guess, it occurs because of the setting of the slats position. I think the actuator is handling these sequential. You see below from the log, that the order is not always the same (sometimes the slats position is set first, sometimes not).

[2/21/2023, 6:00:36 PM] [HomematicIP] Setting target shutter position for Storen rechts to 0 % [2/21/2023, 6:00:36 PM] [HomematicIP] Setting target horizontal slats position for Storen links to 0° [2/21/2023, 6:00:36 PM] [HomematicIP] Setting target horizontal slats position for Storen rechts to 0° [2/21/2023, 6:00:36 PM] [HomematicIP] Setting target shutter position for Storen links to 0 %

I set the actuator in the Homematic IP app to roller mode. Is there a possibility to exclude the slats feature in the Homebridge config as well?

fr3akst3r commented 1 year ago

Also still having the issue. setting the actuator in BROLL mode is kind of a pity, as you just lose the slat setting function, don’t you?

sidthekid87 commented 1 year ago

Yes, you are right about that. But at least my automations would maybe work again.... The best would be: First set the opening level, then wait until this height is reached, and then set the tilt. Not sure, if this would be an Homekit thing or a plugin thing...

Maybe this isn't even the real issue. I'm just guessing at the moment.

sidthekid87 commented 1 year ago

It really seems to be the slats positioning command which causes the chaos. Manual opening / closing over Homekit result in following log entries:

image

Closing over a scene in Homekit results in this commands:

image