search

mario-eth / soldeer

Solidity Package Manager written in rust
MIT License
240 stars 26 forks source link

Support sub-dependency locking for package versions compatibility #211

Open palinatolmach opened 1 month ago

palinatolmach commented 1 month ago

It would be helpful if Soldeer introduced a mechanism for sub-dependency locking to avoid conflicts and integration issues if package versions are not aligned.

For example, while it's not a strict requirement, we recommend that users of Kontrol cheatcodes also install newer versions of Foundry standard library forge-std (>= v1.9.3) to maximize compatibility between cheatcodes.

beeb commented 3 weeks ago

Hey! Thanks for the suggestion. I think this would require a radically different handling of subdependencies than we have now.

At the moment, the system is pretty simple: for each dependency that is a foundry project, run the forge soldeer install or forge install command in the dependency's directory. Each dependency can have its own soldeer.lock where the exact version is specified and that will be the installed version.

This works and is desirable in most cases because each project can use their own requirements and their own remappings and foundry will resolve that correctly.

Regarding your use-case you would like to specify in the kontrol-cheacodes dependency, that any dependent uses forge-std>=1.9.3 alongside kontrol-cheacodes? I think this is better done as documentation personally.

Since dependencies are not flattened, we don't have a reason to perform a resolution step to find a single version that would match all direct and transitive dependencies requirements. And because of foundry's remappings mechanism, having all dependencies installed at the top-level would likely not work.