search

mariuszhermansdorfer / SandWorm

Augmented Reality Sandbox for Grasshopper & Rhino
MIT License
20 stars 11 forks source link

Add multi-frame output to capture sand changes over time #46

Closed philipbelesky closed 4 years ago

philipbelesky commented 4 years ago

The use case here is to be able to scrub backwards in time in order to examine how the sand/mesh changes over a particular period. The immediate use case I have for this is an analog simulation of dune drift (basically by way of pointing fans at the sand). For that purpose, I would want to capture a sequence of meshes over a given time period to visualise the change and be able to perform analysis between the different states. This would likely have value in other forms of simulation — e.g. a Cantrell-style setup for fluvial processes.

Being able to set the tick rate helps here, and data dams help further, but it would be ideal if the outputMesh list was able to be added to by successive solves rather than replacing each solve. That should be easy enough, my question is whether it should be in the main component (with an additional option in SandWormsetup? I'm imagining a simple IntegerParameter along the lines of 'stored frames' which, if set, appends new meshes to outputMesh up to a certain size. If that size is hit, the earliest items in the sequence start getting removed.

I'm running a workshop with this use case in mind this week, so should be able to sketch out an implementation and PR based on how that goes.

mariuszhermansdorfer commented 4 years ago

Love the idea of using a fan to transform the dune landscape! Please make sure to send some updates from your workshop.

For performance reasons, you'd probably like to have it run as part of the main component. Having an additional option in SandWormSetup makes total sense.

mariuszhermansdorfer commented 4 years ago

Should this be part of SandWorm 1.0 release?

mariuszhermansdorfer commented 4 years ago

Curious about the workshop results @philipbelesky. Care to share any insights and photos of the forms you ended up modelling?

philipbelesky commented 4 years ago

Most of the workshop ended up being pretty standard applications of the table as the 'wind' devices we had brought along were either far too weak or far too powerful to do a good simulation of drift. The multi-frame output was useful as a way to capture a 'build up' of landform over time by someone who was looking at a dredging/deposition process.

Once students' projects are a bit further along there might be a few follow up sessions with a chance to further refine the models/techniques used in the table.