[Question] ts2fable on p5.ts

[anpin]

Hi @mark-gerarts, thank you for your effort, glad I'm not the only one who looks into using f# for some "creative coding". I'm curious if you have tried to use ts2fable on p5.ts to eliminate manual labor from making the interop?

[mark-gerarts]

I'm glad as well!

I originally started out by researching ts2fable, but ultimately decided against it for a few reasons.

First off, ts2fable doesn't work out-of-the-box on the p5js TypeScript bindings. There is some manual labour needed, as explained in this wonderful response on an issue I opened.

Secondly, p5js functions use a lot of optional and nullable variables, and variables that can have multiple types. A few years ago, @aolney created a demo project that was based on a ts2fable conversion (it was the inspiration for this project actually!). As you can see in the basic template, there are a lot of extra things going on, e.g.

• p.mouseIsPressed |> unbox<bool>
• p.fill(0.0 |> U4.Case1)
• p.rect(...) |> ignore

Manually creating the bindings results in somewhat "cleaner" code, without unboxing, ignoring, and unnamed unions.

For example, to create a point in p5js, you have a single function with the following options:

• point(x, y, [z])
• point(coordinate_vector)

Which I chose to implement as 3 separate functions wihtout nullable arguments: point, point3D, and pointFromVector.

In the same vein, lastly, the manual process allows for some more functional alternatives where possible. Color functions (e.g. fill) can be called in a lot of different ways in p5js, again by overloading the parameters. The can be represented with a union type instead:

type Color =
    | RGB of r: float * g: float * b: float
    | RGBA of r: float * g: float * b: float * a: float
    | Grayscale of intensity: float
    | GrayscaleA of intensity: float * alpha: float
    | Name of string
    | Values of float seq
    | P5Color of P5Color

I have to concede that creating the bindings manually is a lot of work, and not something that I can finish quickly since my time is limited until the summer. So if there are alternative solutions, I'd definitely be happy to hear them!

[anpin]

Thank you for thorough explanation. I will start playing with this project then. In case I find this approach entertaining and will stumble upon uncovered API would you be open to PR's?

On a side note, I'm very curious if it would be possible to combine fable repl with this library to achieve "creative coding ide for f#" in a static webpage. Similar to how p5 web editor works.

[mark-gerarts]

Any PRs or even just remarks/suggestions are very welcome! Keep in mind that you best clone this repository, as the version on nuget is outdated. I haven't done any research yet to check if nuget updates can be pushed automatically, so for now it'll only get updated sporadically.

A Fable repl with this package is a really nice idea indeed. I think it would be pretty straightforward to fork the repl project and add a dependency. The harder part would be to host it somewhere. Food for thought once the implementation work is done.

[anpin]

Already made a fork, ported it to net7/fable4 and started a boilerplate project with vite server which updates very fast, will keep tinkering. thanks for your effort again!

[mark-gerarts]

I look forward to the PR('s) then :slightly_smiling_face: Definitely also interested in the boilerplate project