markziemann / SurveyEnrichment2

A systematic investigation of enrichment analysis rigour
MIT License
0 stars 0 forks source link

How to get articles that have used enrichment tools? #1

Open markziemann opened 1 year ago

markziemann commented 1 year ago

The desired criteria are:

It would be impractical to search full text or in all bibliographies.

markziemann commented 1 year ago

One strategy is to look at "cited by" articles for commonly used tools. For example, DAVID recommends users cite two articles:

We can look at the "cited by section". PMID: 19131956 has 18k results and PMID: 35325185 has just 391.

It can be downloaded in different forms, from normal citation, to csv, to medline formats.

markziemann commented 1 year ago

The next step is to figure out how to match up the journal to the impact factor. This could be a time sink if it needs to be done manually.

markziemann commented 1 year ago

JIF is paywalled, but SJR can be downloaded from here: https://www.scimagojr.com/journalrank.php?min=200&min_type=cd

As for setting a threshold, here are some interesting SJR scores:

Based on this, <3 is low, >5 is high and 3-5 is middle. Will discuss with Team

JCR data can be read into R with the following:

sjr <- read.csv("scimagojr 2022.csv",header=TRUE,sep=";")

Then it can be filtered for high impact papers.

Then, using the ISSN as the key, the SJR score can be added to the citations.