martin-fleck / cra-ttc2016

The Class Responsibility Assignment Case for the Transformation Tool Contest 2016
3 stars 2 forks source link

Alex Burdusel evaluation of Excel #24

Open alxbrd opened 8 years ago

alxbrd commented 8 years ago

Performance

The execution time required to find the models using this solution allows us to rank this solution in the 3rd place, right after Henshin and NMF but before UML-RSDS.

Optimality

The solution, however, has obtained good overall CRA results, and can be ranked 4th based on overall CRA score, after Henshin but before SIGMA.

The algorithm chosen for this solution is very fast in comparison with most of the other solutions.

Flexibility

The solution can be extended for other optimisation problems, but it would require some developer effort to adapt it so that it works with other requirements.

Complexity

The solution is custom built for the case study. Although it’s one of the fastest solutions, if the problem requirements change, the authors would be required to adapt a big portion of the solution to cater for a different problem.

It has not been easy to run the solution locally on any other OS except for Windows. The SHARE image provided has been helpful and allowed us to correctly evaluate the solution.

EvaluationSheet-EXCEL.xlsx