search

martin-pe / maitreya8

Other
110 stars 54 forks source link

Bug: Astakavarga calculation wrong #33

Open ossiviljakainen opened 6 years ago

ossiviljakainen commented 6 years ago

Birth data used: 18.09.1975 00:19 (AM), Joensuu, Finland. Timezone GMT+2, no daylight saving

The points are totally different in sarvastakavarga between Maitreya8 and JHora: Sarvastakavarga Maitreya 8:

image

Sarvastakavaga JHora:

image

The points are exactly the same for Ascendant, Su, Me, Ju, Ve and Sa in Maitreya8 and in JHora. But different for Mo & Ma.

Maitreya 8 all planets: image

JHora: image perfect

Parashara's Light: image

JHora and Parashara calculate Ashtakavarga correclty and give the same result. Maitreya calculates differently and gives different result.

Bug report contributed by: Virendra S Battu

martin-pe commented 6 years ago

Maitreya does not count the ascendant in sarvashtakavarga in default config. You can change the behaviour: config->vedic calculation->Ashtakavarga-> sarvashtakavarga with ascendant. The result is similar to the output shown above. maitreya_sarva_av There is one difference in Moon's AV. Maitreya has a difference in Karanaprad for Moon in 9th house (mercury and mars exchange). Result is that one point moves to another Rasi. This is not compliant to BPHS but to Jataka Parijata. I will document the details later on the website, but need some time because this is quite cumbersome work :)

saraswathimurugan2020 commented 4 years ago

After adding ascendant ( config->vedic calculation->Ashtakavarga-> sarvashtakavarga with ascendant.)in the configuration, the results were different for all the positions. without that, the calculation of the moon alone was not matching. I think there is something you need to fix.