0027-how-to-retire-old-codes

[JaGeo]

How to treat old (non-core) codes of MP

Context and Problem Statement

Some codes in the context of the Materials Project have only been developed based on short-term funding, and long-term support is hard/impossible to guarantee. This code might still be used in the community. One of the recent example codes is Matminer that triggered the discussion.

Decision Drivers

• These codes are still useful to the community
• There will likely not be any long-term funding for such codes

Considered Options

Use specific versions of the dependencies (via toml or setup.py-based installations) and then release a final version (or release candidate)

• Good as the code can still be used
• Bad as it might not be easy to use together with other software

  Transfer code ownership to a fork outside of MP (if someone wants to take over code)

• Good as the code will still be maintained

  Give maintaining rights to people outside of MP

• Good as more people can merge and contribute
• Not clear how such a decision can be made

  Ask on the repo if someone might want to take over

• Good as someone else might maintain the code in the future
• Connected with transferring code ownership to someone else

Decision Outcome

Implementation Plan

More Information

[JaGeo]

@Andrew-S-Rosen Could you help updating this PR with your suggestion? I am not sure I got all details on the release candidates.

[JaGeo]

I personally think we can vote on this decision the next time.